Thursday, November 4, 2021

Tropic of Cancer by Henry Miller

 

Source of book: I own this

 

This was my selection for Banned Books Week. Just as a reminder, I use the week to read books which have been banned, which means that a government has outlawed sale, publication, or possession of the book. I do not count challenged books - those which citizens or parents have sought to keep out of school curricula or libraries. This isn’t because I think challenges are uninteresting, but because I wanted to focus my once-a-year project on those where the power of the state was employed in censorship. I believe that is a different level from a challenge. After all, any library has limited space and budget, and decisions must be made. (Personally, I would have preferred an extra - and local - copy of The Rest is Noise rather than one of the 20ish copies of Eat, Pray, Love.) Likewise, students can only study so many books, and the choice of which to study is a judgment call.

 

Here are my past selections, plus the introduction to Banned Books Week.

 

Thoughts on Banned Books Week

Areopagitica by John Milton (2011)

Uncle Tom’s Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe (2012)

The Quest for Christa T. by Christa Wolf (2013)

Palace Walk by Naguib Mahfouz (2014)

All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque (2015)

July’s People by Nadine Gordimer (2016)

Into the River by Ted Dawe (2017)

Catch-22 by Joseph Heller (2018)

Strange Fruit by Lillian Smith (2019)

Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China by Jung Chang (2020)

 

***

 

As I have mentioned in previous posts about banned books, they tend to be banned for one of two reasons. Sometimes, it is because of alleged “obscenity” - that is, sexual content. This is a fairly new phenomenon, connected with the neo-Puritianism that arose in the 19th Century and culminated in the jihad against all things sexual by Anthony Comstock. Furthermore, the definition of “obscenity” has changed over time and place, and is a moving target at best. 

On the other hand, the second reason books are banned has been popular since books were invented: politics. Dictators from time immemorial have been unable to handle criticism, preferring to be treated as gods, and have thus banned books that failed to offer the desired level of worship.

 

This book is in the first category, deemed “obscene” by American authorities, and banned from import for thirty years after its first publication in France in 1934. 

 

I first discovered this book in law school, as it was part of a series of cases on “obscenity” and free speech. The history is rather fascinating. Miller published first in France, where laws have always been far more permissive. (In fact, in the Western world, it is really the Puritan-dominated United States and England that has consistently gotten their panties in a knot over sex.) 

 

First, the US Customs department deemed the book obscene and refused to let it be imported. Naturally, this meant that it was smuggled in instead. The seller was sued but not criminally charged. The smugglers, to my knowledge, were never caught. Next, Jacob Brussel, a bookseller and publisher, printed an edition in the US, claiming it was actually printed in Mexico. In addition to the obscenity issue, Brussel also violated copyright law by stealing the work and not paying royalties. He spent three years in prison over the book. 

 

In 1950, the ACLU set up a case by having a director attempt to import the book. In the subsequent trial, the ACLU offered declarations from no fewer than 19 experts as to the literary merit of the book. They still lost. 

 

In 1961, sensing that the winds of change were blowing, Grove Press took a risk and published the book. Immediately, over 60 lawsuits across the US were filed against the booksellers who carried it. This blew up into a huge kerfuffle, with court rulings all over the map as to whether the book qualified as “obscene” or not. One of these cases resulted in a rather purple dissenting opinion by Justice Musmanno - one of the most colorful characters to sit on the bench. More about him in a note at the end, including choice quotes from the opinion. 

 

Finally, in 1964, the US Supreme Court put an end to the chaos and declared that the book was constitutionally protected as part of a series of cases published simultaneously that established that sexuality does not itself make a work obscene - of the work has artistic merit, it is not obscene, and is protected by the first amendment. 

 

So, a fascinating history. Also interesting is how many authors really liked the book, and considered it important in the history of literature. There were plenty who disliked it as well, of course, although even they tended to grant that it had merit and should never have been banned. 

 

***

 

So much for the legal history. What about the book itself? 

 

Having read it, I can say in good faith that anyone who finds this book to be a turn-on is either a bit depraved, or has no idea what good sex looks like. Because the last thing this book made me want to do was have sex. Particularly not sex with a never-ending sequence of Parisian prostitutes, other men’s wives, or gold digging (and probably mentally ill) women. Or, for that matter, with underaged girls. 

 

For one thing, the sex sounds deeply unpleasant, unfulfilling, and not even really desired. For another, if Henry Miller and his bohemian buddies were like this in real life, I doubt they ever in their lives left a woman feeling satisfied afterward. These bros were terrible in bed, and not just because they treated women like meat, or because they were usually drunk, or because they didn’t care about anyone they slept with. They also seem incompetent and not particularly eager to learn anything about women or sex. I’m pretty sure I did better my first time than they did after a year of fucking their way across Paris. 

 

Fortunately, while there is plenty of sex and sexual language in this book - Miller particularly likes saying “cunt” apparently - there is more to the book. 

 

I wouldn’t say that the book has a plot. Rather, there are episodes that have a bit of an arc. But in between are stream-of-consciousness sections, philosophical musings, pessimistic reflections, and, occasionally, something to tie it together. 

 

How much of the book is truly autobiographical and how much is fiction is not clear. The characters were based on real people, most of whom have been identified. The basic action is from Miller’s life. He left his estranged wife and fled to Paris during the Depression. He and his friends struggled to support himself, particularly since unemployment was high and growing. At one point, he was homeless and starving, and some of these passages are pretty harrowing. At the same time, he wants to write a book. And, like so many authors, he wants it to be more “real” and less constrained by form. It was an era. 

 

I was fairly strongly reminded of Kerouac, who wrote in somewhat the same basic style a couple decades later. There are differences, of course, but the blending of autobiography and fiction, the stream of consciousness, the search for enlightenment, the picaresque episodes - it really matches up pretty well. I think I prefer Kerouac, for two reasons. The first is just style: I like his writing better. Second, though, is that instead of the incessant sex and misogyny, Kerouac tends to just drink himself into a stupor. Don’t get me wrong, Kerouac is pretty bad with women too, but the thrust (sorry) of his books aren’t primarily about sex. 

 

As far as the writing, I have mixed feelings. On several occasions, I finished a passage and thought, “wow, that was really great and evocative and moving.” After others, I felt like the prose was far too purple for my taste. And after still others, I couldn’t decide if it was good or too much. I’m not sure “uneven” is the right way to put it. The writing is right on the edge of overwrought, and occasionally spills over. (And the same can be said of Kerouac…and plenty of others.)

 

What there should be no question of is that the book has significant artistic and literary merit. It is definitely not pornography, and isn’t nearly as graphic as it could have been. Mostly, you get a lot of “cunt” and descriptions that are better described as “frank” than “explicit.” So, you find out, for example, that Miller hates shaved vulvas, and prefers his women to be a bit thicker than average. And you also learn a bit about how businesslike prostitutes are. This is not a turn on for either Miller or the reader. But the descriptions do make the squalor of his circumstances come to life. 

 

Here is an example of some of the language:

 

At the Cité Nortier, somewhere near the Place du Combat, I pause a few minutes to drink in the full squalor of the scene. It is a rectangular court like may another which one glimpses through the low passageways that flank the old arteries of Paris. In the middle of the court is a clump of decrepit buildings which have so rotted away that they have collapsed on one another and formed a sort of intestinal embrace. The ground is uneven, the flagging slippery with slime. A sort of human dump heap which has been filled in with cinders and dry garbage. The sun is setting fast. The colors die. They shift from purple to dried blood, from nacre to bister, from cool dead grays to pigeon shit. Here and there a lopsided monster stands in the window blinking like an owl. There is the shrill squawk of children with pale faces and bony limbs, rickety little urchins marked with the forceps. A fetid odor seeps from the walls, the odor of a mildewed mattress. Europe - medieval, grotesque, monstrous: a symphony in B-mol. 

 

It’s a good bit of writing, but also a bit over the top. It is also not the Paris of the tourist areas, to say the least. 

 

Here is another memorable line, applied to one of the various artist sorts that flits in and out of the book. (This one isn’t tied to a real-life person that I can find.)

 

It seems to me that Papini misses something by a hair’s breadth when he talks of the need to be alone. It is not difficult to be alone if you are poor and a failure. An artist is always alone - if he is an artist. No, what the artist needs is loneliness.

 

Probably the best example of the casual misogyny of the group of bros comes from Carl, who is patterned after the writer Alfred Perles. Carl is the one who sleeps with an underaged girl later in the book, and essentially pays the girl’s dad off afterward. Before that, he is sleeping with an older and wealthy woman, and then complaining about it to Miller. 

 

Listen, Joe, she’d be all right if she were just a little younger. You can forgive a young cunt anything. A young cunt doesn’t have to have any brains. They’re better without brains. But an old cult, even if she is brilliant, even if she is the most charming woman in the world, nothing makes any difference. A young cunt is an investment; an old cunt is a dead loss. All they can do for you is buy you things. But that doesn’t put meat on their arms or juice between the legs. 

 

 Yeesh. That’s harsh, and reveals the general approach Carl (and the rest, unfortunately) have toward women. Pieces of flesh. Better to be without brains. I am the complete opposite of that - I would rather have an intelligent woman, and no level of beauty would ever overcome stupidity. Also, Benjamin Franklin had much more intelligent things to say about sex with older women. (And also with a better sense of humor than Carl.) 

 

I also have to quote another instance of purple prose, this one a description of Matisse. I think it is evocative, although I think my experience of Matisse is a bit different, perhaps.  

 

In every poem by Matisse there is the history of a particle of human flesh which refused the consummation of death. The whole run of flesh, from hair to nails, expresses the miracle of breathing, as if the inner eye, in its thirst for a greater reality, had converted the pores of the flesh into hungry seeing mouths. By whatever vision one passes there is the odor and the sound of voyage. It is impossible to gaze at even a corner of his dreams without feeling the lift of the wave and the cool of flying spray. He stands at the helm peering with steady blue eyes into the portfolio of time. Into what distant corners has he not thrown his long, slanting gaze? Looking down the vast promontory of his nose he has beheld everything - the Cordilleras falling away into the Pacific, the history of the Diaspora done in vellum, shutters fluting the froufrou of the beach, the piano curving like a conch, corollas giving out diapasons of light, chameleons squirming under the book press, seraglios expiring in oceans of dust, music issuing like fire from the hidden chromosphere of pain, spore and madrepore fructifying the earth, navels vomiting their bright spawn of anguish…He is a bright sage, a dancing seer who, with a sweep of the brush, removes the ugly scaffold to which the body of a man is chained by the incontrovertible facts of life. 

 

And it goes on for another page.  

 

The description of homelessness could have been written in our own time. He sees Paris as a place where everyone - even the roaches are snuggly inside - while those outside freeze. Later in the passage, he recounts trying to get a place to sleep in Florida from various churches, and being turned away by all of them. (Jewish and Christian both…) 

 

If you haven’t a sou why just take a few old newspapers and make yourself a bed on the steps of a cathedral. The doors are well bolted and there will be no draughts to disturb you. Better still is to sleep outside the Metro doors; there you will have company. Look at them on a rainy night, lying together and protected by the newspapers against spittle and the vermin that walks without legs. Look at them under the bridges or under the market sheds. How vile they look in comparison with the clean, bright vegetables stacked up like jewels. Even the dead horses and the cows and sheep hanging from the greasy hooks look more inviting. At leas we will earth these tomorrow and even the intestines will serve a purpose. But these filthy beggars lying in the rain, what purpose do they serve? What good can they do us? They make us bleed for five minutes, that’s all. 

Oh, well, these are night thoughts produced by walking in the rain after two thousand years of Christianity. At least now the birds are well provided for, and the cats and dogs. 

 

It’s a decidedly bitter reflection, from one who literally lived it. I can’t blame him for seeing Christianity (the dominant religion in the West, after all) as primarily responsible for the wreckage of lives during the Great Depression, and the callous disregard that the destitute were treated with. And, honestly, most of the white Evangelicals I grew up around still hate FDR for the New Deal. Here is a bit more, from a visit a drunken Miller and a friend pay to a cathedral. 

 

All over Christendom, at certain stipulated hours, people in black are groveling before the altar where the priest stands up with a little book in one hand and a dinner bell or atomizer in the other and mumbles to them in a language which, even if it were comprehensible, no longer contains a shred of meaning. Blessing them, most likely. Blessing the country, blessing the ruler, blessing the firearms and the battleships and the ammunition and the hand grenades. 

 

Miller also expresses his disgust with Americans who think of France as somehow exotic and different, rather than just another human civilization. I think this sums up the Ugly American pretty well - and Miller is indicting himself too. 

 

I never saw a man who was so infatuated with a country, who was so happy under a foreign sky. It wasn’t natural. When he said France it meant wine, women, money in the pocket, easy come, easy go. It meant being a bad boy, being on a holiday. 

 

But that’s the way humans are. We glorify some place, whether that is another country, our own, the rural, the urban, whatever. But wherever we go, there we are. 

 

There are other episodes that were interesting. The one where he takes a temporary job teaching - for room and board only, no pay - is a reminder of what happens without government regulation of wages, particularly in times of hardship. His description of the constant tension between the needs of survival, and the needs of the human spirit is compelling. Through it all, his indictment of a decadent and soulless culture seems even more relevant today. 

 

My particular copy of this book is from the first (legal) US edition from Grove Press. I inherited it from a legal colleague and friend who was downsizing. I believe he purchased it used prior to that. It contains the original introductory material - an introduction by Karl Shapiro, and a Anaïs Nin, friend and lover of Miller and later “Carl,” and who is probably a character in the book. 

 I own this exact trio of Grove Press editions of Miller's most popular books. 

From Nin’s preface, written for the original French publication:

 

The predominant note will seem one of bitterness, and bitterness there is, to the full. But there is also a wild extravagance, a mad gaiety, a verve, a gusto, at times almost a delirium. A continual oscillation between extremes, with bare stretches that taste like brass and leave the full flavor of emptiness. It is beyond optimism or pessimism. 

 

It’s a pretty good description throughout its short three pages. 

 

Shapiro’s introduction was written specifically for the Grove edition in 1961, and has several gems. At the outset, he recommends replacing the Gideon Bibles in hotels with the book, and putting the bibles in the laundry chutes. I may not go that far, but it is an amusing thought. 

 

He also quotes the book, and I thought that quote would go well here. 

 

Man is not at home in the universe, despite all the efforts of philosophers and metaphysicians to provide a soothing syrup. Thought is still a narcotic. The deepest question is why. And it is a forbidden one. The very asking is in the nature of cosmic sabotage. And the penalty is - the afflictions of Job.

 

Shapiro also sums up a central issue of modern American life that I think resonates even more in the era we live in, when the common good is no longer considered a worthwhile goal by one of our political parties. 

 

In America it has become impossible, except for a few lucky or wise people, to live one’s own life; consequently the poets and artists tend to move to the fringes of society…The American way of life has become illusory; we lead the lives of prisoners while we boast about free speech, free press, and free religion, none of which we actually do enjoy in full. 

 

Ironically, Tropic of Cancer tears the mask off of American emptiness through a tale set in Paris. The fact that it took three decades for this book to legally make it to American bookstores is evidence that Miller was in fact right. I suspect, in fact, that one of the reasons it was banned was not so much the sex and language, but passages laying out the moral bankruptcy of organized religion at home and abroad, and how society in the 1930s turned away from the death and destruction and crushing poverty it caused and then refused to remedy. 

 

I wouldn’t say this is my favorite book, but I think it is a worthy read. If only Miller could have gotten past the misogyny, I would have found it less tedious in places, and I wonder how the book would have been if he had seen that women were suffering even more than him and his bohemian buddies. 

 

***

Note on Musmanno:

 

So, Justice Michael Musmanno was quite the character. I am teaching a Wills and Trusts course at our local law school this semester, and one of his other cases (on a question of reciprocal wills) came up. The text gives a sidebar on the man himself, and quotes from his dissent in the Pennsylvania case involving Tropic of Cancer. Here are some choice bits from that opinion:

 

‘Cancer’ is not a book. It is a cesspool, an open sewer, a pit of putrefaction, a slimy gathering of all that is rotten in the debris of human depravity. And in the center of all this waste and stench, besmearing himself with its foulest defilement, splashes, leaps, cavorts and wallows a bifurcated specimen that responds to the name of Henry Miller. One wonders how the human species could have produced so lecherous, blasphemous, disgusting and amoral a human being as Henry Miller. One wonders why he is received in polite society.

…

Policemen, hunters, constables and foresters could easily and quickly kill a thousand rattlesnakes but the lice, lizards, maggots and gangrenous roaches scurrying out from beneath the covers of ‘The Tropic of Cancer’ will enter into the playground, the study desks, the cloistered confines of children and immature minds to eat away moral resistance and wreak damage and harm which may blight countless lives for years and decades to come.

…

To say that ‘Cancer’ has no social importance is like saying that a gorilla at a lawn party picnic does not contribute to the happiness of the occasion.

…

The defendant would have reason to say that ‘Cancer’ is not hard-core pornography; it is, in fact, Rotten-core pornography. No decomposed apple falling apart because of its rotten core could be more nauseating as an edible than ‘Cancer’ is sickening as food for the ordinary mind. ‘Cancer’ is dirt for dirt’s sake, or, more appropriately, as Justice Frankfurter put it, dirt for money’s sake.

 …

Then the defendants say that ‘Cancer’ is entitled to immunity under the First Amendment because court decisions have declared that only worthless trash may be proscribed as obscene. To say that ‘Cancer’ is worthless trash is to pay it a compliment. ‘Cancer’ is the sweepings of the Augean stables, the stagnant bilge of the slimiest mudscow, the putrescent corruption of the most noisome dump pile, the dreggiest filth in the deepest morass of putrefaction.

 

I take it he was not impressed by the book. 

 

But there is more to his story. An Italian American of devout Catholic faith, he was one of the biggest supporters of the movement to make Columbus Day a holiday. His last notable dissent was in a rape case, where the majority reversed the conviction because the judge told the jury that they would have to answer to God for their decision. 

 

Musmanno disagreed and warned the other judges that they would have to face God on Judgment Day, while he felt he was rather well prepared. 

 

In one of the greatest examples of cosmic irony, he literally dropped dead the next day…on Columbus Day. 

 

Tuesday, November 2, 2021

Girls Kill Nazis (Empty Space 2021)

 

There is a saying so old that nobody is sure when or where it originated, but it is to the effect that if you either have to laugh or cry. Laughing is one way of coping with things that are too terrible to face without either humor or despair. 

 

As a brilliant illustration of that truth, Girls Kill Nazis exists. 

 

Let’s see, the last five years have given us with the rise of an obvious fascist who has now completely captured one of our two major political parties. Not only did the neo-Nazis salute him with a seig heil, not only did he praise those marching with swastikas and changing Nazi slogans as “very fine people,” he literally tried to overthrow the US government so he could stay in office. And the end of this storyline is far from clear right now. There is a genuine likelihood that the Republican Party will end democracy in America the next time they are in power. That so many object to my calling this fascist is astonishing. It is literally textbook fascism, the kind you find in the Britannica article on the subject, or in Umberto Eco’s fine long-form discussion of the essential elements of fascism. I have come to the conclusion that some are just in deep denial and wishful thinking; but also that many on the right, particularly white evangelicals, are actually fully in favor of fascism if they can run it. 

 

Girls Kill Nazis is set in a not-very-distant future, when the American Nazi Party has come into power, and is forcing its particular version of authoritarianism on the nation. 

 

The play opens with a public service announcement, sponsored by the Evangelical Nazi Church of America. (Not subtle, but all too true right now.) The announcement encourages [white] Americans to “blow their whistle” when they see certain things. Things like “more than two Muslims speaking together,” or “colored folk out after dark,” or “Mexicans working without papers.” None of these seem as implausible as they did when I was a kid, that’s for sure. 

 

As we soon find out, the title is both literally true, and also a commentary on the sexist attitudes of the Nazis, who keep calling the strong women featured in the play “girls.” But these women literally kill Nazis. The leader, Ruth, runs the local library, to the annoyance of the Nazi males. "Well I guess a man didn't want the job and someone has to run this place." 

 

Ruth has already killed 20 Nazis, and intends to kill as many as possible before she gets caught. Which she fully intends. Just not yet. As she notes, she would have turned herself in long ago…but she isn’t done killing Nazis yet. 

 

Ruth is joined by her young assistant, Sidney, a Hip Hop aficionado who is just done with all the sexist micro and macro aggressions she puts up with every day. These are all too familiar to anyone who watches chauvinist pigs belch their way through life casually demeaning women and girls. Just one example is from the drunken father who comes in to complain about Harry Potter, and can’t resist telling Sidney "Hell girl, do you even own any makeup? If you smiled more I bet you would look pretty, who knows in time you might even get a boyfriend." 

 

Ruth hadn’t really intended to be more than a lone wolf, driven by her anger at mistreatment by her Nazi ex-husband and the disrespect she continues to get from so many others. But Sidney accidentally discovered all those heads in jars hidden behind a panel, and…well, she too was down for some casual murder. 

 

And then there is Diana, a yoga instructor who killed a Nazi in self-defense, and liked the experience. 

 

The final member of the “Nancy Wake Book Club” (named after the famed Nazi killer, of course) is the seemingly scatterbrained little old lady Betty, who tearfully confesses that she killed her husband when he went all Nazi on her. Using poisoned lemon bars, which play a key role in the rest of the play - apparently they work on ex-husbands too. 

 

Everything is going swimmingly until their club (which does discuss books, and tries to leave the killings for other times - I mean, priorities, right?) is crashed by Bob. Well, crashed may be a little strong. Actually, there was a signup sheet, and he put his name down. But not only had nobody ever signed up for the club, certainly no man had ever considered doing so. 

 

Bob was hilarious. He is an old hippie with a good heart, but not always a lot of sense. One of the ongoing jokes is that Bob never reads the books, he watches them. That is, he watches the movies. But he also is a HUGE Maya Angelou fan - he calls himself a “fangelou.” Bob has no idea that the club is about killing Nazis, and it is doubtful if he could ever kill anyone himself. However, as he reveals in a discussion of To Kill a Mockingbird, he agrees with the townspeople - and the Sheriff - who looked the other way when Boo Radley killed Bob Ewell. Which is exactly what he is convinced to do when he accidentally witnesses the women killing a Nazi. 

 

Rounding out the characters are an assortment of Nazis (including Ruth’s ex-husband), and Bob’s son Horowitz, the Mexican-American sheriff of the Arizona town the play is set in. Sheriff Horowitz is no friend of the Nazis, but he is in the bind of decent law enforcement everywhere, often caught between duty in a broken system, and the desire to do the good he can in his position. 

 

I won’t go any further into the plot, which is full of fun twists, scary moments, and slapstick violence. It is not, shall we say, subtle. But that isn’t the point. It says the truth loud and proud, and without concern for “good taste.” As Ruth puts it:

 

"Women killing Nazis is nothing new. It's just part of the story. If these walking abortions want to glorify a page from history, I say we show them what's on the next page."

 

And that really is the story. Fascism is nothing new: it is an evil that has existed since humans first discovered violence and tribalism. But along with that has always come the resistance, the good people of the world who stand up to those who reduce humanity to racial and gender hierarchies (which is really the core of Nazi belief, after all.) Whether we who resist do it like Corrie Ten Boom, who along with her family hid Jews in their home until they could be smuggled to safety; or like the teen girls who killed Nazis, or like the resistance members who risked their lives to publish the truth about the Nazi regime, we are all crucial to changing the direction of history, of pushing back against evil. 

 

This was my first time back to The Empty Space since before the pandemic, although we did catch When We Were Young and Unafraid as a virtual event during the closure. One of the things that makes me happy is that all our local theaters made it through the pandemic. As I have noted about TES, they combine low prices, small budgets, and an intimate space with high artistic and production values. They are a real credit to our community

 Members of the Nancy Wake Book Club
Bob, Ruth, Betty, Diana, and Sidney

The casting was great as usual. Claire Rock had the lead as Ruth, and was fantastic as usual. (Her Tybalt four years ago was one of my favorite performances ever.) In her scenes in this one where she stares down Nazis with guns, she is entirely believable. When you are unafraid of death, you have the advantage. 

 

I hardly recognized Maya Blackstone as Diana, as she looked a bit different than in other productions, but she has a great stage presence, and brought a “biker-chick” vibe to the role. She is another young actor worth watching. 

 

Kate Gill was relatable as Betty, with just enough ditz to make the role comic but not so much as to undercut her competence as a killer. 

 

Elizabeth Bomar has been in a number of productions as part of the ensemble, but I don’t think I had seen her in a lead role. She has long impressed me with her physicality and energy, but she was great in the role of Sidney. 

 "I thought we agreed not to kill during book club..."

In the role of the sheriff, Divyang Motavar brought a bit of small town folksiness. I don’t recall seeing him in anything previously, so he is new to me. 

 "Are you sure you haven't seen him?"

And then there was Bob. Ed French is another longtime stage regular (sometimes under the pseudonym of “Lord Skudley”) who is always fun to watch. As the main comic relief in this show, he was hilarious. And often touching, as when Sidney gives him a “fangelou” t-shirt. His shirts throughout the show are fun, and I think he owns most of them. (Including the “If your parents reject you for being LGBTQ, I am now your family” one.) 

 Dude, you're about to be owned by your ex-wife and her girlfriends.
Also, you look stupid in that uniform, which is SO 19th Century.
Ruth and Todd (Jordan Fulmer)

But what is a show like this without villains? The villains were great in this show, all of them very convincing and loathsome and oh-so-killable. Which is kind of fun because in real life, they are so far from horrible. So, Janice Bondurant, Morgan Roy, Nate Pugh, and Jordan Fulmer, you guys were great. I mean nasty and evil and good riddance. And all that. Good performances, enjoyed your work too even as I cheered for your deaths on stage. 

 "Clowns to the left of me, jokers to the right."
Sidney, irritated at Buck (Morgan Roy) and Tina (Janice Bondurant), who have occupied the upper floor of the library for the Nazi headquarters. But don't worry, they'll be dead soon enough.

I know I am leaving out a few ensemble people, and the sound and light crew. You guys were great too. In fact, I should probably call out John Morrison for the fantastic soundtrack. And yes, that bit of Mysterious Mountain by Hovhaness caught my ear. 

 

Unfortunately, we went to the last weekend of the show, so it is too late to see it now. But consider the other shows at TES this and next year. The best bang for the buck you will ever find. 

 

And Nazis, take note. We’ve seen this show before, and we know how it ends. Eventually, you will lose. I may not live to see it, but my kids probably will. And as long as human history is kept, you and your orange messiah, your great white hope, will be held in the same contempt as your forebearers. 

 

***

 

Note on exhibit: 

 

Usually, TES has an art exhibit to go with each production, featuring local artists. You can buy the artwork, so it serves both as a fundraiser and a way for local artists to make a living. 

 

This time, however, they did an exhibit featuring the various women who resisted the Nazis, including the ones mentioned above. 

 

I forget which of the teens it was, but the best story of all was about one of her assassinations. She was tiny, and looked far younger than she was, and could impersonate a child. On one occasion, she marched up to the local headquarters and asked to see the head honcho, using euphemism to indicate that she was pregnant out of wedlock. She was allowed up to see her “lover,” then shot him dead with a silenced gun, and slipped out the back door. That’s badass. And also telling that it apparently was “normal” for Nazi leaders to fuck underaged girls. But that is also neither new nor of the past. Jeffrey Epstein, anyone? (And anyone who thinks Il Toupee hasn’t sexually assaulted underaged girls wasn’t paying attention in the 1980s…) 

 

Great exhibit, and really added to the event.