Source of book: Audiobook from the library
This is the second book I have read by Erin Entrada Kelly. I previously listened to her Newbery Award-winning first book, Hello, Universe back in 2019.
While The Land of Forgotten Girls does have some similarities to the other book, it is in other ways very different.
What I would say they have in common is the focus on children who are marginalized, both in their families, and in the broader society. Like the mother of the author, the narrator of this book is Filipino-American, an immigrant who came to the United States as a child.
The story of Soledad and her younger sister Ming is a sad one, and the book as a whole is pretty darn heavy. It’s more about surviving bad things through sibling love and solidarity than about anything getting better.
Several years back, the middle sister, Amelia, drowned in an accident that Soledad feels is partly her fault. Not too long after this, her mother dies of cancer.
At the time, the family was living in the Philippines, with the process of immigration already underway.
Another woman, Vea, sees her opportunity and gets the girls’ dad to marry her, and the four of them settle in Louisiana.
Not too long after, however, the girls’ dad abandons them with Vea, moving back to the Philippines to take up with another woman.
So, the girls are now stuck with Vea, who is bitter and nasty about being stuck with girls she doesn’t want and doesn’t like. While one can feel sorry for some of the circumstances Vea is faced with, her abuse of the girls - physical and emotional - is indefensible. Unfortunately, having grown up in neighborhoods where poverty and abandonment were not uncommon, Vea felt pretty real.
Living in poverty in Louisiana has some challenges to say the least. And having an evil stepmother as one’s only family forces Soledad to function far beyond her mere twelve years of age, functioning as a surrogate mother to Ming.
To this end, she continues her mother’s tradition of telling stories, primarily about her mother’s imaginary sister Jove, who is a dashing adventurer who Ming becomes convinced will come rescue them.
Not that much “happens” in the book. It is more of a sequence of happenings in the life of Soledad, and her learning to cope with the terrible situation she is in.
While Vea never gets better, from what I can tell, there are other characters who are revealed as different from how Soledad perceives them.
The next apartment neighbor, Mrs. Yeong, a Chinese immigrant whose English is shaky, but whose heart turns out to be kind, ends up taking the girls in from time to time, and functioning like a grandmother would.
Soledad has a best friend, Manny, a Mexican American kid from similar economic circumstances, is a good guy, if a bit of a typical boy of his age. The main tension here is that Manny is developing feelings for Soledad, who feels too caught up in her unhappy life to consider romance.
One particularly heartwarming storyline involves Caroline, a very white and privileged girl from the local Catholic school. The first encounter between the girls does not go well, with Soledad injuring Caroline with a pine cone. But Soledad does the right thing and tracks Caroline down and apologizes, and the two end up becoming friends. (It is also cool that Caroline’s family appears to have no issues with their kids hanging out with low income brown kids - that was my childhood too.)
And then there is “Blackbeard,” the caretaker of a local junkyard the kids break into, who turns out to be a lot nicer than his outward persona.
In this sense, then, the book is about Soledad’s journey of finding friends of all sorts. She is still stuck with Vea, she still is essentially an orphan, and she will inevitably have trauma from the abuse.
But she is resilient, intelligent, and a lot tougher than she thinks. Even if standing up to Vea doesn’t always go well for her, she continues to do it, and give a good example to Ming. Her willingness to take responsibility for her mistakes also serves her well, and is at the core of how she makes friends from unexpected places.
In some ways, I think this book is better plotted than the earlier one. It doesn’t feel like loose ends were left, even though there is no real “end” to the story. It’s pretty dark for a kids book, but, as George M. Johnson pointed out in his excellent YA book, All Boys Aren’t Blue, plenty of kids experience the dark things in this book every day. It doesn’t do them any service to promise that things will magically get better (although there is a place for books that fantasize a better ending) - so this book sits with the bad stuff, and shows an example of survival and maturity.

No comments:
Post a Comment