Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The Land of Forgotten Girls by Erin Entrada Kelly

Source of book: Audiobook from the library

 

This is the second book I have read by Erin Entrada Kelly. I previously listened to her Newbery Award-winning first book, Hello, Universe back in 2019. 

 

 

While The Land of Forgotten Girls does have some similarities to the other book, it is in other ways very different. 

 

What I would say they have in common is the focus on children who are marginalized, both in their families, and in the broader society. Like the mother of the author, the narrator of this book is Filipino-American, an immigrant who came to the United States as a child. 

 

The story of Soledad and her younger sister Ming is a sad one, and the book as a whole is pretty darn heavy. It’s more about surviving bad things through sibling love and solidarity than about anything getting better. 

 

Several years back, the middle sister, Amelia, drowned in an accident that Soledad feels is partly her fault. Not too long after this, her mother dies of cancer. 

 

At the time, the family was living in the Philippines, with the process of immigration already underway. 

 

Another woman, Vea, sees her opportunity and gets the girls’ dad to marry her, and the four of them settle in Louisiana. 

 

Not too long after, however, the girls’ dad abandons them with Vea, moving back to the Philippines to take up with another woman. 

 

So, the girls are now stuck with Vea, who is bitter and nasty about being stuck with girls she doesn’t want and doesn’t like. While one can feel sorry for some of the circumstances Vea is faced with, her abuse of the girls - physical and emotional - is indefensible. Unfortunately, having grown up in neighborhoods where poverty and abandonment were not uncommon, Vea felt pretty real. 

 

Living in poverty in Louisiana has some challenges to say the least. And having an evil stepmother as one’s only family forces Soledad to function far beyond her mere twelve years of age, functioning as a surrogate mother to Ming.

 

To this end, she continues her mother’s tradition of telling stories, primarily about her mother’s imaginary sister Jove, who is a dashing adventurer who Ming becomes convinced will come rescue them. 

 

Not that much “happens” in the book. It is more of a sequence of happenings in the life of Soledad, and her learning to cope with the terrible situation she is in. 

 

While Vea never gets better, from what I can tell, there are other characters who are revealed as different from how Soledad perceives them. 

 

The next apartment neighbor, Mrs. Yeong, a Chinese immigrant whose English is shaky, but whose heart turns out to be kind, ends up taking the girls in from time to time, and functioning like a grandmother would. 

 

Soledad has a best friend, Manny, a Mexican American kid from similar economic circumstances, is a good guy, if a bit of a typical boy of his age. The main tension here is that Manny is developing feelings for Soledad, who feels too caught up in her unhappy life to consider romance.

 

One particularly heartwarming storyline involves Caroline, a very white and privileged girl from the local Catholic school. The first encounter between the girls does not go well, with Soledad injuring Caroline with a pine cone. But Soledad does the right thing and tracks Caroline down and apologizes, and the two end up becoming friends. (It is also cool that Caroline’s family appears to have no issues with their kids hanging out with low income brown kids - that was my childhood too.) 

 

And then there is “Blackbeard,” the caretaker of a local junkyard the kids break into, who turns out to be a lot nicer than his outward persona.

 

In this sense, then, the book is about Soledad’s journey of finding friends of all sorts. She is still stuck with Vea, she still is essentially an orphan, and she will inevitably have trauma from the abuse. 

 

But she is resilient, intelligent, and a lot tougher than she thinks. Even if standing up to Vea doesn’t always go well for her, she continues to do it, and give a good example to Ming. Her willingness to take responsibility for her mistakes also serves her well, and is at the core of how she makes friends from unexpected places. 

 

In some ways, I think this book is better plotted than the earlier one. It doesn’t feel like loose ends were left, even though there is no real “end” to the story. It’s pretty dark for a kids book, but, as George M. Johnson pointed out in his excellent YA book, All Boys Aren’t Blue, plenty of kids experience the dark things in this book every day. It doesn’t do them any service to promise that things will magically get better (although there is a place for books that fantasize a better ending) - so this book sits with the bad stuff, and shows an example of survival and maturity. 

 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Spinach King by John Seabrook

Source of book: Borrowed from the library

 

Sometimes, you discover a book through a series of seemingly random choices. The story behind this selection:

 

This summer, some friends and I did a five-day backpacking trip in the eastern Sierra Nevada, and had lunch in Lone Pine afterward. On a whim, we decided to visit the tiny local library - sometimes you can get an out-of-town library card that expands the available audiobooks. (I have a Los Angeles Public Library card for this reason…) 

 

While Inyo County doesn’t issue cards to non-residents, we did have a good conversation with the librarian, and looked around the shelves. One of the books featured was this one. It seemed to be the kind of off-beat nerdy read that I like, so I put it on my list.

 

And yes, it did in fact turn out to be quite the trip. 


 

Even if you have never heard of Seabrook Farms, you probably have seen some of the brands founded by it, such as Bird’s Eye. And, if you had relatives of a certain age and taste, you probably have eaten creamed spinach, which was the company’s signature crop. 

 

As you might have guessed, this book was written by a member of the family that founded the company. This makes for an insider perspective, although I did find the final chapters a bit self-indulgent. 

 

First, a bit about the company. The author’s great-great-grandfather Samuel first bought farmland in southern New Jersey in the 19th Century. He failed, but his son Arthur succeeded, running a “truck farm” selling produce in the New York City area. 

 

This went on for some time, until Arthur’s son Charlie (aka C. F.) got involved, and decided to build the business into something bigger. Much bigger. C. F. took on a wealthy investor, and bought out his father for far below market value. 

 

The company under C. F. went modern, using irrigation, greenhouses, fast freezing techniques, and a bunch of other industrial practices that we now take for granted, but which were revolutionary in their time.

 

At its height, the farm produced fully one-third of all the frozen vegetables in the United States. 

 

As C. F. aged, however, he became addicted to alcohol and barbiturates, and became increasingly paranoid. His three sons were practically running the business, and were poised to have great success, when C. F. decided to torpedo the whole thing, selling the business out from under them. 

 

After this, the brothers, including the author’s father, ended up involved in other businesses, all too often involving grift and government contracts, but apparently legal enough to avoid consequences. 

 

The author took a totally different track, going into journalism, and eventually writing a number of non-fiction books. 

 

Before his father’s death, the author gained access to archives of the past, interviewed the surviving relatives, and did some serious digging into primary sources regarding the company. He found more than a few skeletons, but also a lot of interesting history. 

 

Thus, this book manages to include the KKK and the racial dynamics of a certain era. The KKK helped the company break strikes in the 1930s. But the company was also notable for a multi-racial workforce. 

 

On the one hand, the company wasn’t particularly generous with its African American workers, it did hire a lot of Japanese Americans from the internment camps. These workers and their descendants have worked to preserve the company history.

 

The book also looks at the way different marginalized groups have been played off each other to maintain white supremacy and economic power. The Italian immigrants versus the African Americans. The Japanese immigrants against the eastern Europeans. And so on. 

 

Less expected was how much this book includes Hollywood. The author’s father hob-nobbed with the movie stars, dating Eva Gabor, and becoming close enough friends with Grace Kelly that he was invited on the famous wedding cruise. 

 

It was on that cruise that he met the author’s mother, his second wife: she was a journalist on the cruise, and they hit it off. 

 

If you are interested in upscale clothing, or horses and carriages, or agriculture, or labor, or a whole host of other things, you might find something to like in this book. The Seabrooks were a complicated, dysfunctional family, and the author brings them to life in all their messiness. 

 

As the author notes:

 

We often bury the details of how large fortunes are made, as the brutality underlying them is less inspiring to read about than eureka moments of accomplishment.

 

All too often, the men (and it is usually men) who rise this way do so because of their ruthlessness, their sociopathy and lack of empathy, and single-minded focus on making money. The author quotes one of his mother’s letters to her mother regarding C. F. that is pretty enlightening. 

 

“Jack’s father is without doubt one of the most remarkable men of all time - cunning, domineering and spiteful beyond belief almost…He is a man whose life has been motivated by a single force - to control. He must control the people and the property around him - he knows no security except financial dominance, and he has no basis for having people as friends - only to have them kowtow to him as dependents or to oppose him and be enemies.”

 

The book talks quite a bit about the legendary corruption of New Jersey politics, even noting a black mark on his own resume: while in college, his dad pulled strings to get him an internship with Senator Harrison Williams…right before the Senator went down for accepting bribes. The line the author uses to describe this is so good, I have to quote it.

 

It’s a bouillabaisse of baksheesh. 

 

I imagine the author smiled when he wrote that one. 

 

Another weird and nerdy reference in the book involves the author’s father’s hobby of “four-in-hand” coaching. He owned numerous carriages, but the prize was the Nimrod, which eventually became his identity. As in, vanity license plates, a street sign, and even identifying with the Biblical figure.  

 

Ironically, at the same time, “nimrod” was developing into an insult. When Bugs Bunny started using it to refer to Elmer Fudd, this use of the word went global. 

 

The author ended up marrying a good woman, Lisa, who in addition to her other virtues, had never heard of the Seabrooks and was not impressed with all the money and fine expensive stuff. 

 

My father’s money, finery, and expensive tastes held no sway over Lisa. He realized it, and it made him vaguely uneasy, an amazing thing to see. She knew that kindness and fairness are what overcome the barriers we create to our own happiness, and that was something my father didn’t know. 

 

Another great line about his father reminds me of the prior generation of lawyers, who are now mostly retired or dead, but who dominated the court hallways when I was a young attorney. 

 

Jack Seabrook belonged to perhaps the last generation of businessmen who could go through life without learning how to type - and be proud of it.

 

I recall an instance where opposing counsel’s secretary was out, and he (and it was always a he) literally couldn’t send me an email. 

 

There is a passage in the book describing how C. F. used race on the farm that is worth quoting - it is pretty emblematic of the way Capital has managed Labor here in the United States, thus maintaining a shocking level of inequality. 

 

Black and white workers lived in separate “villages,” an arrangement that was both ideological and political, because it allowed C. F. to play the different ethnic groups off against each other to keep control. Housing workers in separate villages with different levels of amenities helped stoke resentment. On the farm, Blacks were confined to the fields and weren’t allowed to work in the plant at all, to say nothing of management, which was entirely white, Protestant, and male.

 

I love that the book also notes how agricultural workers were exempted from most New Deal legislation benefiting workers. And also why that was done. 

 

Why were farmworkers denied the rights that other American workers enjoyed? Mostly because segregationist Southern Democrats opposed any tampering with the sharecroppers and farmworkers. The workers themselves were mainly people of color who lacked the political power to represent their interests in Washington. 

 

There are also some great lines about the Klan, known as the “White League” in the North. It is striking how much the 1930s version resembles two modern iterations of the Klan: Trump and the MAGA movement, and White Evangelicalism. 

 

Konclaves were family-friendly events that had parades with floats depicting church, home, and school, guarded by Klansmen with flaming swords. Klan christenings used “Klan water,” which could be purchased from the national headquarters. Cross burnings were like fireworks displays. “Packaging its noxious ideology as traditional small-town values and wholesome fun,” wrote Joshua Rothman in The Atlantic in 2016, “the Klan of the 1920s encouraged native-born white Americans to believe that bigotry, intimidation, harassment, and extralegal violence were all perfectly compatible with, if not central to, patriotic respectability.” 

 

Sound familiar? It’s happening again, in full view. And then, as now, racism and bigotry go hand in hand with Purity Culture. From a newspaper article about a club sponsored by the Klan:

 

“The plays and musical comedies put on are absolutely clean with not even lines suggestive of double meanings. The dress of the women will be beyond reproach.” 

 

When the Seabrook workers went on strike, it was unsurprising that the Klan came out in force to violently oppose the strikers. 

 

The Seabrook strike would be a chance for payback, as well as a way to recover some of their former glory through vigilantism. The ethnic makeup of the Seabrook strikers was diverse enough to appeal to anti-Catholics, anti-immigrant nativists, anti-Communists, and anti-Black racists. The union offered an all-you-can-hate buffet.

 

Apparently, there was some video of the violence, and it appears that it was mostly the women strikers who were targeted by the Klan. Go figure. But also, some badass women, standing up against armed men. 

 

The author took some flak for writing about the family, initially in a magazine article about the strike. He would choose to wait until his parents were dead before finishing the book, however. 

 

I know what this dynamic is like. My parents and sister are furious with me for writing publicly about our family. Ultimately, they believe that they own the story, and that I should not have the right to tell my side, particularly when it conflicts with their beliefs about who they are. The author notes this and responds to his mother how I have to my family. 

 

After a silence, my mother said, “I think it’s a terrible idea to write about your family.”

“I know you feel that way,“ I said tensely, “but it’s my story too, and I have a right to it.”

 

Like the author, I also have a sister with a serious personality disorder. And, like the author, this has never been acknowledged by my parents. 

 

Perhaps because of the uncertain loyalties of her childhood, Lizanne tended to see the world in black and white. Talking to her, you walked a minefield of potential faux pas: one wrong step and you were a bad person. Lizanne would rage about small things people had done or not done to her, and perhaps it was the same rage that our grandfather had, and our father knew it when he saw it. After she died, we learned she had been diagnosed with borderline personality syndrome. If our father knew about that, he never told us. 

 

The author talks about his father with a mix of admiration and trauma - Jack wasn’t an easy person to live with, but he was brilliant in his own way. And so were his siblings. His sister, unfortunately, was denied a chance to run the business because she was a woman. His brothers, Belmont and Courtney, did play a role. Perhaps Courtney’s most lasting contribution is the motto the company used on its advertising - one that I remember seeing as a kid. 

 

“We Grow Our Own So We Know It’s Good, and We Freeze It Right on the Spot.” 

 

For the most part, the family drama in the book is really interesting. If the Seabrooks were rich, they were still human, and the drama feels pretty familiar. One incident I noted was when the eldest granddaughter fell in love with a Mexican man, there was all kinds of scandal in the family. (No, not that kind, but…) C. F. went so far as to hire a lawyer to go spy on the guy’s family, the “Mexican N-----rs,” as he called them. 

 

The problem is that the guy was invited in by the family, who was pretty upper-class, and treated him to delicious food and booze. He went back and reported to C. F. that they were “exceptionally cultivated people with excellent taste in all things.” 

 

Again, this was all part of C. F.’s need for control. 

 

C. F. seemed to be intent on prosecuting the morality of his family members, but given his own behavior it’s hard to fathom what principles his stance rested on.

 

The author’s mother sure seems to have been a character. Born in a religious fundamentalist family, she was seen as the ugly daughter - the other one was the star, the favorite, the golden child. 

 

Liz moved east, graduated college, and worked as a respected journalist. But she was also hoping to find a marriage eventually. One of the interesting episodes during her single days was when she did a Sadie Hawkins Day article. For those unfamiliar, this is the day when women ask men out. 

 

So Liz went to Capitol Hill, and started asking congressmen to marry her. One of those was Joseph McCarthy, who reacted awkwardly. The young JFK was more gracious in turning her down. 

 

Another story is the dirt surrounding the marriage of Grace Kelly to Prince Rainier of Monaco. A major player was Aristotle Onassis, the shipping magnate who would eventually marry the widowed Jacqueline Kennedy. 

 

Monaco then as now is a tiny country mostly known as a tax haven for the ultra rich. But apparently as the result of its pretty crazy history, it was granted independence from France but on the condition that if there failed to be a male heir to the throne, it reverted to France. 

 

Hence, it was vitally important that Rainier marry and have a son. And, since Onassis counted on his tax shelter, he had to make sure that this happened, and thus arranged the marriage. 

 

As an interesting postscript, Rainier ended up on the throne until his death in 2005, more than 20 years after Grace Kelly’s death. In 2002, a new treaty with France was enacted, eliminating the heir issue. 

 

As a final fun story, Randolph Churchill, the son of Winston and “famously querulous, lecherous, and dipsomaniacal,” was a guest on the Rainier and Kelly cruise. The author recounts a great quip by Evelyn Waugh. 

 

Randolph developed a benign tumor on his lung, which doctors removed. The Waugh quip:

 

“It was a typical triumph of modern science to find the one part of Randolph which was not malignant and to remove it.” 

 

As a final note, the book seems to lose a bit of steam at the end, for two reasons. One is that once Seabrook Farms is sold and the brothers go their own ways, there is less of interest. The graft is a necessary part of the story, of course, but the old age of rich white guys simply doesn’t have much that matters. 

 

The second part is that there are two chapters at the end (the chapters are all fairly short) which deal with the author’s personal life: his struggles with alcohol (the family curse) and his adoption of his daughter. These two felt self-indulgent to me, particularly the second. But these are minor quibbles. 

 

I do want to mention the sad end that the author’s father made. After retirement, he moved to South Carolina, and sank, as so many of my parents’ generation has, into a stew of bigotry and Fox News. 

 

One of the saddest passages describes the parties that the author’s parents continued to throw, where Jack would say embarrassingly racist and sexist things, causing even his longtime friends to wince. 

 

And then, when Liz dies, everyone stops visiting. They put up with the bigotry only because Liz was such a decent person. And so C. F. essentially dies alone, festering in his own nastiness, a shell of who he was with all the good parts sucked out. 

 

Whether that will ultimately be the fate of my father and others like him is unclear, but already, the racism and misogyny and anti-LGBTQ bigotry have driven my kids away from my parents. It’s a sad story that I think is going to characterize our era, where the older generations love their bigotries more than they love their descendants. 

 

This book really is a fascinating story, and one I enjoyed. 

 

Monday, November 16, 2026

Two One-Act Plays by Lucy Fanucchi (Ovation Underground 2026)

I wasn’t entirely sure what to expect from these two plays, performed at Ovation Underground (Ovation Theatre’s basement), but I felt like I had at least heard something about Straight Play a couple years ago. 

 

Lucy Fanucchi is a local playwright, and I wasn’t able to find much of a biography. About all I could locate was an Instagram account with next to nothing biographical - it even lacked pronouns, which might be helpful here. I did note with approval an abundance of cat pictures. But that is about it I can say about the author.

 

On the other hand, I certainly can say something about the plays themselves, and the particular productions. 

Ovation 9060 

Sebastian Richardson, Mackenzie Flores, Natalee Clark, Ruth Luna, Irving Cortes, Nick Ono 

Ovation Underground seems to be taking on the niche formerly occupied by Stars Playhouse: tiny space, minimal sets, offbeat selections, low cost. I previously wrote about The Real Thing by Tom Stoppard. 

 

I just happened to have a night free, and found the blurbs to be interesting. So my wife and I went. 

 

The two plays are very different in setting. The Pleasures of the Afterlife takes place in a late Victorian English country manor, while Straight Play is contemporary. The sets consisted mainly of two reversible panels, and the period-appropriate things to sit on. Each play has three roles, and each play used a different trio of actors. 

 

The Pleasures of the Afterlife starts out with socialite and gossip columnist Cecelia Sinclair happy to have inherited her uncle’s estate. But as she reads the local paper out loud, we discover that she is unhappy that, after a carriage accident, a rival is writing her column, and doing a bad job. 

 

But things take a turn for the worse: her servant seems to be ignoring her, and a man suddenly appears in her mansion, insisting he lives there too. 

 

Oh, and also that he is a ghost, and maybe she is too. 

 

How inconvenient. 

 

From there, we get a bunch of bickering, a long-kept and dark secret, and a decision that backfires humorously. 

 

Along the way, we get a lot of sparkling dialogue, witty insults, and general comedy. Overall, it was well done, with my only quibble being that there were a couple of times the actors stepped on each other’s lines. And yes, real humans arguing do this all the time, but on stage, you want all the lines to be heard - the jokes have to land, and for that you need all the words. 

 

I do have nice things to say about the acting, though. Sebastian Richardson as Alexander had great physical comedy, and his timing was excellent. He also looks just a bit like Gru (from the various Minion movies), and I think used a few moves. Mackenzie Flores (Cecelia) and Natalee Clark (Miss Mortimer) rounded out the cast, and played well off each other. They maybe should have warned about Clark’s voice, however, because that scream was far more ear-shattering than the gunshot. 

 

Straight Play was a bit longer, and in my opinion, a more fully developed play. It also had absolutely delightful and hilarious dialogue that sounded both natural and unexpected. It was full of double entendres, both intended, and unintended, and much of the humor was (as is a farce tradition) based on characters not knowing what the audience knows. 

 

Lee arrives at a trendy restaurant for a date with Sally - and he intends to propose to her. But it turns out his waiter is Michael, and the two of them dated for a couple of years. The breakup was not, shall we say, amicable. 

 

When Sally arrives, she discovers Michael, and we learn that the two of them dated in high school, before Michael came out - and that he was just the first of several times Sally ended up dating a closeted gay man. 

 

So you have a really awkward love triangle, so to speak, and neither Sally nor Lee knows about the other’s history. 

 

How this all sorts itself out is hilarious and awkward as hell. But it also is all about the process of becoming at home with who you are, with one’s history, and with the complexities of other people’s pasts. 

 

I will mention that all three characters also have a connection to theater, as well as a complicated relationship to that medium. This gives an opportunity to the playwright to use “improv” as the kind of multi-valenced term with a spectrum of double and triple meanings. Kind of like “Stockholm” in Anxious People. 

 

The cast for this one was truly top notch. Nick Ono (as Lee) has been in every kind of local production for years now, and he is one of those veteran actors now who is a joy to watch in any role. He made Lee’s nervousness and vulnerability come to life - and made the reality of bisexual erasure and stigma feel palpable. 

 

Ruth Luna is another stage veteran, most recently seen in The Children’s Hour. Her Sally was of a competent and capable woman who is all too often overlooked in favor of flashier sorts. Both her initial response to Lee and her later softening felt real. 

 

Finally, Irving Cortes brought Michael to life as a man still not over his past loves, still insecure in his present and ashamed of his past. There is a certain nastiness in his behavior, but Cortes rooted it in the character’s trauma and hurt. 

 

Great chemistry among the trio. And the dialogue, I am still thinking about that. The audience was laughing through the whole thing, at least when they weren’t gasping at revelations or wincing at the awkwardness. 

 

Both plays, but especially the second one, are examples of how to write dialogue. It never felt stilted, and every word seemed important and necessary. To write humor that doesn’t feel forced, or like something no real human would say, is a talent. 

 

I enjoyed both of the plays, and hope they find a wider audience as well. 

 

Friday, November 13, 2026

Ring Shout by P. Djeli Clark

Source of book: I own this

 

This is the latest book I read with a couple of my online friends. We need a catchy name for the club, so I can create an index for the books we have read and discussed. 

 

Anyway, this book was nominated by K, who recently graduated from University of Connecticut, and took a class from the author. Since the class was really good, the book seemed like it might be too. 

 

And indeed, it is a good book, and one I can recommend, particularly to readers who like horror or horror-adjacent books. 

 

It’s a pretty cool premise: The 1920s iteration of the Ku Klux Klan, except that the truest believers are actually zombies. 

 

I hesitate to say too much about the plot, because this is a book that shouldn’t be spoiled. I will say, however, that it involves the historic membership induction rally that the Klan held on Stone Mountain in Georgia, a moment that is largely seen as the rebirth of the Klan. The book imagines what might have happened had that rally been, well, interrupted. 

 

As in real life, the rally was inspired by the movie, Birth of A Nation (which was itself based on a book, The Klansman), a glorification of the Klan of the Reconstruction Era. The book sees the movie as a literal witchcraft ritual, to summon unholy spirits. Which, depending on your view of demons, is not inaccurate. 

 

Fighting against the Klan in this book is a group of radical women (some of them queer), aided by the Aunties, who are reminiscent of Mrs Whatsit, Mrs Who, and Mrs Which from A Wrinkle In Time, and supported by their partners. So very much female-centric, gender flipping, and all the good anti-racist vibes. 

 

The enemies are complicated. The Klan members are essentially in two categories: the ordinary Klans, casually racist and the general support for Klan activities, and the Ku Kluxes, who are supernatural and zombie-like despite how normal they might look in daylight. 

 

According to B, who has read a lot of Lovecraft, the book has a lot of nods in his direction, perhaps with a bit of venom directed at his notorious racism and sexism. There is also a bit of a nod at the old “trickster” stories in African American culture. In addition, the cultural background of the book is “Gullah,” the west African turned American system of language, food, art, culture - and witchcraft. The name refers to a ritual dance in Gullah culture, one that has greatly influenced African American music ever since. I highly recommend Zora Neale Hurston’s work, Mules and Men, for an introduction to this culture; and Albert Murray’s book, Stomping the Blues, for the musical origins of Blues in the Ring Shout tradition, and also of the “juke joints,” one of which plays a key role in this book. 

 

Further than that, I will not go as far as plot. I wrote down some great lines, however. 

 

The opening scene, describing a Klan march, is hilarious satire. 

 

A brass band competing with that racket, though everybody down there I swear clapping on the one and the three.

 

If you are a musician, you know. But also, if you (like me) survived Bill Gothard’s cult, or any number of Fundamentalist groups that claimed that music by black people gave you demons, you know exactly how obsessed they were with keeping the beat on one and three. 

 

Another scene has one character talking about his experience fighting in France in the war, and also the French food. 

 

Sadie don’t look convinced. “Well, don’t know what type of white folk they got in France. But the ones here don’t put no proper seasoning in they food unless they got Niggers to do so for ‘em.” 

 

A reminder that most “American” food was actually created by black folk. And oh yes, I do know some Mayo-Americans who seem allergic to proper seasoning. 

 

For those unfamiliar with The Birth of a Nation, the author gives a bit of background. 

 

The Birth of a Nation comes from a book. Two books really - The Clansman and The Leopard’s Spots, by a man named Thomas Dixon. Dixon’s father was a South Carolina slaveowner in the Confederacy. And a sorcerer. Way I hear it, a heap of the big ups in the Confederacy was into sorcery. Dark stuff too. Jeff Davis, Bobby Lee, Stonewall Jackson - all in league with worse than the devil. 

 

Later, Nathan Bedford Forrest gets mentioned as another conjurer. And I agree. White Supremacy is the doctrine of demons. 

 

The explanation of what Ku Kluxes are:

 

Buckrah devils is what she calls Ku Kluxes. Fool buckrah she reserves for Klans who ain’t turned. She very particular about us not killing them who still human. Say every sinner got a chance to get right. I suppose. Way I see it, one less Klan, one less chance of a Ku Klux. But I bides by her rules and shake my head.

 

Exactly what happens to people to turn them into Ku Kluxes is the subject of speculation later in the book. 

 

Molly shakes her head. “We haven’t been able to gauge that. Once infected, morphological transformation seems dependent on the individual.”

That’s science talk for how Klan folk turn Ku Klux. Molly says it’s like an infection, or a parasite. And it feed on hate. She says chemicals in the body change up when you hate strong. When the infection meets that hate, it starts growing until it’s powerful enough to turn the person Ku Klux. Ask me, it’s plain evil them Klans let in, eating them up until they hollow inside. Leave behind bone-white demons who don’t remember they was men.

 

I feel pretty much the same way about the MAGA virus. It feeds on the hate people already had in them, and manifests as them forgetting their humanity. 

 

The book also has an interesting discussion of Marx, and why seeing everything as being about labor versus capital is problematic in a place like the United States. Racism drives essentially everything in American politics, and as much as a better division of GDP favoring labor would be a good thing, it will not be enough to create social equality. And, sadly, it is still working class white people who are the first to sling hate and violence against black people. 

 

As many have pointed out before, poor white people might suffer economically from their political choices. Heck, it can even be literally killing them. But they still get something out of white supremacy that they see as important. 

 

“We must strive to show them they too are exploited. And not by those they are taught to hate, from which they earn nothing.”

“Oh see, I disagree,” Chef retorts. “White folk earn something from that hate. Might not be wages. But knowing we on the bottom and they set above us - just as good, maybe better.”

 

The book also notes the way that Jewish and black people were set against each other, rather than becoming allies. There is a brief reference to “Mr. Frank,” who is the subject of the musical, Parade. You can read my post about that for more on the story, and how the case ended up having prejudice against both Jewish and black people driving the events. 

 

Another great passage involves my distant relative by marriage, Charles Darwin. By the time this book is set in, it was widely understood in scientific circles that all humans originated in Africa. Hearing this leads a character to have a big epiphany. 

 

“White folk is niggers!” Sadie repeats, slamming her glass hard enough to make Lester jump. “This whole time, they putting on and acting high and mighty! But they just niggers who stayed in the cold too long! Bet that’s why they so mean. Know deep down they come out that same jungle - that the nigger they made up in their heads right under they own skin!” 



I recognized another thing from my own history in the raid on the juke joint by the Klan midway through the book. The leader, Butcher Clyde, is waiving a Bible above his head, and saying things white preachers so love to say. 

 

“Brethren, we must do our best to stamp out the vices in our midst! Fornication! Drinking! Heathen music! It’s left to us to correct the waywardness of these simple minds, as a father must govern his children and home - delivering stripes onto the wicked so that they might be persuaded to follow a straight path.” 

 

One of the bits of wisdom the Aunties impart is about the idea that there are multiple potential futures. 

 

Aunt Margaret sighs. “Girl, every choice we make is a new tomorrow. Whole worlds waiting to be born.”

 

At the beginning of each chapter, there is a short bit about a particular Gullah shout. This one was my favorite:

 

The Shout Eve and Adam tell ‘bout them two listening to that wicked snake and eating the fruit of the forbidden tree. When God call out, Adam don’t answer. So He get to asking Eve. She say Adam going ‘round to pick up leaves to hide his nakedness, now that he know shame. When we do that Shout, we go ‘round pretending to gather up leaves like Adam, hiding from the Lord. Suppose we making fun but it’s a warning too - be mindful of getting mixed up with old wicked snakes.

 

I’ll quote this one because it made me laugh. 

 

It’s raining the Sunday night we make our way up Stone Mountain. 

Not no Presbyterian rain neither. I’m talking a shaking and hollerin’ Baptist downpour.

 

And this description of the big Klan gathering on Stone Mountain:

 

All here to see their god be born.

 

For those of us who were Evangelicals, but left, it is so obvious that Trump has become their new god, and that his rallies are just another Klan rally, which in turn are just another manifestation of the old revivals, just centered around a particular kind of god. 

 

It is a bit of a spoiler, but one of the main plot points is that the Klan leader offers Maryse the chance to become a right wing leader, so to speak. To turn Uncle Tom. 

 

I found it fascinating that when she expresses the risk to her own leader, the response is this:

 

“Got to trust the soldier next to you will do the right thing. No use worrying about it.”

 

Another interesting bit is the confrontation between Clyde and Maryse. He understands full well how racism works emotionally. 

 

“As you know, we specialize in that thing you call hate. To your kind, it’s just a feeling. A bit of rage behind the eyes that can drive you to commit all sorts of beautiful violence. But for us, those feelings are a power of their own. We feed on it. Treasure it as life.” He turns to the gathered Klans. “Look at all that beautiful hate. We didn’t put it there, was always growing inside. Just gave it a nudge to help it blossom. A few reels of celluloid and they come to us whole and willing.”

 

Again, MAGA in a nutshell. But the problem is that that kind of hate is weak. It has nothing real behind it. 

 

“You see, the hate they give is senseless. They already got power. Yet they hate those over who they got control, who don;t really pose a threat to them. Their fears aren’t real - just insecurities and inadequacies. Deep down they know that. Makes their hate like…watered-down whiskey.” 

 

When I think of the incomprehensible hate that right wingers have toward transgender people, who pose literally no threat whatsoever, this line rings true. It is just about their own insecurities about their own masculinity or femininity, and their inadequacies at ever succeeding at being manly or womanly enough, whatever those mean. And of course this goes for racism and misogyny too. 

 

In the end, what Clyde offers Maryse is a common enough temptation - perhaps why a certain famous temptation is in the Bible. 

 

What they are offering me is power. Power to protect. Power to avenge. Power over the life and death of my people. When colored folk ever had anyone offer us so much? When we ever have the power not to be scared no more? Ain’t we been suffering and dying all this time, at the hands of monsters in human form? What then if we make a pact with some other monsters? What we owe this world that so despises and brutalizes us? Why lift a hand to save it when it ain’t never done a damn thing to save us?

 

It is fitting, then, that the final battle comes down to music. To the Shouts. 

 

It’s like the night at the juke joint. A mashed-up chorus, with no real timing or rhythm. As if it was created to unmake music. Like before it threatens to take me off balance and I stumble under it. But no! I got songs too. I listen to my sword, letting those chanting voices fill me up. For a moment it seems the two are battling: my songs and his uneven chorus. But it was never a real fight. What I have is beautiful music inspired by struggle and fierce love. What he got ain’t nothing but hateful noise. Not a hint of soul to it. Like unseasoned meat. 

 

I have mentioned before that genre fiction isn’t really my thing. That said, I can enjoy it if it is truly well written. This book may be horror, fantasy, gothic, whatever you want to call it, but it is really good, and I quite enjoyed it. It’s a quick read, not that long, but tightly plotted, economically written, and a ripping good yarn. 







Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Winter of Our Discontent by John Steinbeck

Source of book: I own this

 

I have read a number of Steinbeck books over my lifetime. The Grapes of Wrath pre-dates this blog, but here are the other ones that I have written about:

 

Cannery Row

East of Eden

Of Mice and Men (Novel)

Of Mice and Men (Play)

The Red Pony

Tortilla Flat


 

The Winter of Our Discontent is Steinbeck’s last novel, and one that is often overlooked when listing his works. For whatever reason, it was never as popular or respected as his earlier novels.

 

While as a general rule, I think it is a bit silly to worry about spoiling books that are older than I am, this is one case where I will give a spoiler warning. I am going to have to discuss plot points from late in the book in this post, but will give a warning in case the reader wishes to stop in order to go read the book. 

 

Astute readers will recognize the source of the title, from the opening lines of Shakespeare’s play about Machiavellian power games, Richard III. 

 

Now is the winter of our discontent

Made glorious summer by this sun of York 

 

The line itself doesn’t appear in the book until near the end, but its use in the title should give some clues about the book itself. 

 

The book will center around an anti-hero, who, much like (the fictional) Richard III, decides to take advantage of circumstances to elevate and enrich himself, unfortunately at the expense of others. And, like with Shakespeare’s anti-hero, success doesn’t bring happiness, but only destruction. 

 

That said, unlike Richard III, Ethan Allen Hawley isn’t a pure villain, not by half. He is more like a Greek tragic hero, damned by the fates, caught up in an amoral capitalist game that rewards vice and punishes virtue. 

 

It is a testament to Steinbeck’s writing that as much as I was horrified by the depths to which Ethan sunk by the end of the book, I also had a lot of sympathy for him, and a feeling that the moral issues weren’t nearly as black and white as I wanted to think. (I’ll talk more about them in the section with spoilers.) 

 

The book is seriously cynical and bitter, but also an incredible critique of the immoral heart of capitalism; an uncomfortable examination of the complexities of race, class, and immigration; and a question about who “deserves” success in society and economy. 

 

Consider it a very different book from The Grapes of Wrath in that sense. You can’t completely like anyone in this book, except maybe Ethan’s daughter. Everyone else is to some degree or another tainted by the society they live in. 

 

Ethan is from a formerly aristocratic East Coast family. His ancestors were whalers, before becoming store owners. However, his father managed to squander the fortune, leaving Ethan working as an underpaid clerk in the grocery store his family used to own. 

 

To make things worse, his own family resents their lowered social status, and blame Ethan for lacking ambition. 

 

As we gradually learn, one of the reasons Ethan’s father lost the fortune was through some devious insider dealings from the bank owner, Mr. Baker, which probably included burning a ship for the insurance money, thus putting the losses mostly on Ethan’s father. 

 

The new owner of the grocery store, Mr. Marullo, is an Italian immigrant, who has risen from poverty through a combination of hard work and ruthless business acumen. And Ethan’s low wages are one of the ways he retains profitability. So he is both admirable and an oppressor at the same time. But he too is ground in the wheels of capitalist profit-seeking. 

 

Ethan served in World War Two, as did his family friend, another former aristocrat, Danny, who has turned to alcohol to cope with his PTSD. All that Danny has left is the old family property, which he thinks is worthless except for pride. 

 

Meanwhile, Ethan’s wife’s best friend, Margie, is trying to seduce him, while using her fortune telling skills to encourage him to take a financial risk to better his fortunes. 

 

I should mention the unusual way the book is written. It is in two parts, and at the beginning of the two parts, the chapters are in third person, although mostly from Ethan’s point of view. Then the book switches to first person. I’m not entirely sure why Steinbeck does this. 

 

At this point, I think I have to stop before giving spoilers. So much of what happens in the book is important to my thoughts about it. Hence, stop here if you haven’t read the book, and come back later. 

 

***

 

Ethan starts off the book as perhaps even a bit too upright for his own good. He turns down a chance at a bit of a kickback from a supplier. He brushes off the banker’s suggestion that he raid his wife’s modest inheritance to invest in a project in the expanding and gentrifying Sag Harbor. He tries to do the right thing whenever he can. 

 

But, as the book goes along, he succumbs to temptation, and eventually commits two pretty lousy acts, although, as I had to admit, there was a level of moral ambiguity present. 

 

Through listening and paying attention, Ethan comes to realize two things. First, Marullo is an undocumented immigrant, and thus vulnerable to deportation. (Hey, this book feels timely…) 

 

The second is that the land Danny owns is coveted by developers (including Mr. Baker) as the only viable site for an airport. 

 

Suddenly, Ethan has two options available that just require a bit of ethical contortion. He also decides on a third: to gain some operating capital, he will use his friend Joey’s (the bank clerk) inside information to pull off a bank heist. 

 

The first two are pretty successful. An anonymous tip leads to Marullo’s arrest, and leverage to purchase the store at a discount. Ethan borrows a bit of his wife’s inheritance and gives it to Danny, with the express instructions that he should check himself into rehab. Knowing full well that Danny will (and does) promptly drink himself to death instead. Oh, and Ethan knows that Danny, having no family left, has left the property to Ethan’s wife. 

 

The third, however, ends up interrupted, so Ethan never does rob the bank. 

 

Everything ends up great for him on the surface. He gets a bit of long-awaited revenge on Baker and Marullo, is given the store by Marullo (who believes Ethan is honest), and is able to insist on a controlling interest in the development of the airport. 

 

Conscience is a bitch, though, and Ethan isn’t able to live with himself. Compounding this is that his son wins an essay contest by ripping off speeches from past statesmen. This is only found out when Ethan’s daughter blows the whistle, thus getting her revenge on her insufferable older brother.

 

So, here is where things get a bit morally ambiguous. 

 

Ethan would prefer that Danny actually get help. And, he does essentially offer that help. Meanwhile, Baker has tried to trick Danny into selling the property, so Ethan is essentially protecting Danny’s interest. In fact, he was willing that Danny should get the profits, except that Danny is so removed from reality that he refuses to even consider selling. 

 

If not for the fact that Ethan knows full well that Danny will drink himself to death - indeed, fully intends to - Ethan’s actions might be considered moral. And even then, he merely hastens the inevitable. Danny will do himself in fairly soon anyway, and in the meantime, Ethan has just taken an advantage that may well have gone to Baker instead. 

 

And I shed zero tears that Baker gets the short straw. He has lived his life by the immoral demands of profit, and has not hesitated to ruin good men to make money. So anything he loses is fine by me. If only Danny hadn’t had to die. 

 

The other case is tougher. Marullo isn’t an admirable character. He is ruthless in his business dealings, putting competitors out of business. He cuts wages to the bare bone. He is condescending in his treatment of Ethan. 

 

On the other hand, deportation of someone who has lived in the country for decades, built a business, and been a member of society, is immoral in itself. This is the evil of our immigration laws - both the one from 1920 that excluded Jews, Italians, Greeks, and Asians; and our current one that excludes most non-white immigrants from an opportunity to immigrate legally. 

 

Ethan’s revenge on his employer is disproportionate. But it also reveals racist and classist beliefs. Part of why Ethan seethes about his lowly clerk position is that his family used to be something. He sees himself, not as working class, but as a member of the aristocracy. 

 

And worse yet, his family store is owned by a “dago,” a “wop,” one of those dirty immigrants that wouldn’t even be considered “white” for another decade or two. 

 

And yet, Ethan still has a conscience. It bothers him that, rather than just getting a good deal on the store, he is given it because Marullo mistakenly believes Ethan is honest and upright. Kind of the Horatio Alger karma thing. 

 

But this is the problem. Being honest is a serious disadvantage in our capitalist, profit-worshipping system.

 

It is possible, at least sometimes, to do okay on honesty and reputation. But to actually become rich, you have to be ruthless, and that means harming other people on the way up. Or at least looking the other way while the system harms them. 

 

To get into all the ways this book looks at that idea would take too much space. I do, however, want to share a number of excellent lines. 

 

I’ll start with the dedication, which is pretty spot on. 

 

Readers seeking to identify the fictional people and places here described would do better to inspect their own communities and search their own hearts, for this book is about a large part of America today. 

 

There are many passages lovingly describing the grocery store. 

 

The store was greeny from the drawn shades over the big front windows. Again shelves to the ceiling, filled neatly with gleaming canned and glassed foods, a library for the stomach. 

 

This line reminds me so much of my own wife, who can go from crawling into bed to dead out in under 10 seconds. Maybe it is those decades of working night shift. 

 

My wife, Mary, goes to her sleep the way you would close the door of a closet. So many times I have watched her with envy. Her lovely body squirms a moment as though she fitted herself into a cocoon. She sighs once and at the end of it her eyes close and her lips, untroubled, fall into that wise and remote smile of the ancient Greek gods. 

 

In contrast to Mary, whose inner life we never really know, is Ethan, who struggles to sleep, and who is always inside his own head, something I certainly understand. 

 

“Ethan, you’re talking in your mind. I don’t know what it’s about but it’s loud. Stop thinking, Ethan.”

 

Another line is about Ethan’s ancestors, who often freelanced a bit on the sea, shall we say. 

 

They successfully combined piracy and puritanism, which aren’t so unalike when you come right down to it. Both had a strong dislike for opposition and both had a roving eye for other people’s property. 

 

And one of many about money, both as a thing, and as an idea encompassing the profit motive, and also in light of the dubious origins of his own family’s money.  

 

Money not only has no heart but no honor nor any memory. Money is respectable automatically if you keep it a while. 

 

Thus the money from piracy becomes “old money” and thus status, if you wait long enough. 

 

This one, about stories, rings true as well. 

 

A man who tells secrets or stories must think of who is hearing or reading, for a story has as many versions as it has readers. Everyone takes what he wants or can from it and thus changes it to his measure. Some pick out parts and reject the rest, some strain the story through their mesh of prejudice, some paint it with their own delight. A story must have some points of contact with the reader to make him feel at home in it. Only then can he accept wonders. 

 

This applies double for sacred texts, of course. 

 

No one wants advice - only corroboration. 

 

And the hits keep on coming. How about this insight, which seems applicable to MAGA in our time?

 

When a condition or a problem becomes too great, humans have the protection of not thinking about it. But it goes inward and minces up with a lot of other things already there and what comes out is discontent and uneasiness, guilt and a compulsion to get something - anything - before it is all gone. 

 

There is also a paragraph about the Campbellites, one branch of which became the Church of Christ, with its ban on musical instruments for worship. (One of our neighbors as a kid was a minister at a small Church of Christ - he was a good man, whatever our theological differences.) Back in the day, another branch got heavily into the predictions of Christ’s return. I found this paragraph rather intriguing. 

 

I remember a story Aunt Deborah told me long ago. Early in the last century some of my people were Campbellites. Aunt Deborah was a child then, but she remembered how the end of the world was coming at a certain time. Her parents gave everything away, everything they owned but the bed sheets. Those they put on and at the predicted time they went to the hills to meet the End of the World. Dressed in sheets, hundreds of people prayed and sang. The night came and they sang louder and danced and as it got near time there was a shooting star, she said, and everybody screamed. She could still remember the screaming. Like wolves, she said, like hyenas, although she had never heard a hyena. Then the moment came. White-dressed men and women and children held their breaths. The moment went on and on. The children got blue in the face - and then it passed. It was done and they were cheated out of their destruction. In the dawn they crept down the hill and tried to get back the clothes they had given away, and the pots and pans and their ox and their ass. And I remember knowing how bad they must have felt. 

 

There is still a strain of this in the American Religion. “Cheated out of their destruction” sums it up pretty well. 

 

Another passage analyzes the way that corruption is part of the social fabric to the degree that we don’t recognize it. 

 

The men who governed it, politically, morally, economically, had so long continued that their ways were set. The Town Manager, the council, the judges, the police were eternal. The Town Manager sold equipment to the township, and the judges fixed traffic tickets as they had for so long that they did not remember it as illegal practice - at least the books said it was. Being normal men, they surely did not consider it immoral. All men are moral. Only their neighbors are not. 

 

One of the best chapters in the book is Margie’s unsuccessful attempt at seduction of Ethan. Wherever Ethan’s weaknesses are, they do not lie in that direction. 

 

Margie’s back story ties in with the themes of the book. When she divorced her first husband, she was awarded alimony, which she has lived off of for decades. However, his health is failing, and when he dies, she will be out of luck, so finding another man to support her is necessary. 

 

But she in a way respects Ethan too much to play the game, and instead offers too much information about herself, perhaps in an effort to scare him off. Her analysis of most men may explain her actions. 

 

Margie had known many men, most of them guilty, wounded in their vanity, or despairing, so that she had developed a contempt for her quarry as a professional hunter of vermin does. It was easy to move such men through their fears and vanities. They ached so to be fooled that she no longer felt triumph - only a kind of disgusted pity. 

 

This too reminds me a bit of MAGA - Trump plays on the same fears and vanities as Margie, but he gets played in turn by smarter operators like Putin. 

 

Another one regarding Margie, who I think is an excellent character. 

 

Margie liked Mary Hawley very much and she had little sympathy and no pity for her. Misfortune is a fact of nature acceptable to women, especially when it falls on other women. 

 

Oh, do I know women like this. Hell yes. 

 

Margie also turned down Mr. Baker on an occasion, and the reason is interesting. 

 

Baker had made a grammatically correct but obscure pass at her once. Mr. Baker was Mr. Money. Sure he had a wife, but Margie knew the Bakers of this world. They could always raise a moral reason for doing what they wanted to do anyway. She was glad she had turned him down. It left him still in the book. 

 

Ethan spends a lot of time thinking, as I mentioned, and we get his thoughts. This one is another musing on business, and the amorality of the profit motive. 

 

What are morals? Are they simply words? Was it honorable to assess my father’s weakness, which was a generous mind and the ill-founded dream that other men were equally generous? No, it was simply good business to dig the pit for him. He fell into it himself. No one pushed him. Was it immoral to strip him when he was down? Apparently not. 

 

And more:

 

If it succeeded, they would be thought not crooked but clever. And if a factor they had overlooked moved in, would that be immoral or dishonorable? I think that would depend on whether or not it was successful…Strength and success - they are above morality, above criticism. It seems then, that it is not what you do, but how you do it and what you call it. Is there a check in men, deep in them, that stops or punishes? There doesn’t seem to be. The only punishment is for failure. 

 

This seems to be the philosophy of MAGA, and indeed the Republican party. It is failing not because of how deeply immoral and unethical it is, but because it is incompetent and failing. This is to me and many others deeply troubling. It seems Steinbeck may be right, that most people lack a basic conscience that would check their behavior. 

 

Ethan ties all this back to the war, in that “morality” for a soldier is simple: kill on command. The rest of it doesn’t matter. 

 

He could devote his full capacity, untwisted by conflicting thought and feeling, to the job he had to do - the killing of men. He was the best officer I ever knew. I asked his permission to use his method and he gave it to me. When he was killed, all I could think was that his had been a good and effective life. He had taken his pleasure, savored his love, and paid his debts, and how many people even approached that? 

 

I’ll end with a line that Ethan delivers to Mr. Baker after revealing that he essentially has gone behind his back to seize the opportunity afforded by Danny’s land. 

 

“You’ll feel better, sir, when you have got used to the fact that I am not a pleasant fool.”

 

Again, I have zero sympathy for Baker: he has lived his life profiting off the misery and misfortune of others, so it is high time someone got the better of him. 

 

The book is definitely cynical, and more than a bit bitter. Perhaps that didn’t much match the mood of 1961, with JFK recently elected. But it seems to fit our own times all too well. 

 

As always, I found Steinbeck’s writing to be compelling, even in a book as unpleasant at its emotional core as this one. It’s worth a read. 

 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

American Humor: A Study of the National Character by Constance Rourke

Source of book: I own this

 

From time to time, I read old books that have fallen into relative obscurity. I do this for a few reasons. First, I like the perspectives of the past. I think they are helpful in understanding the present, and often serve as a correction to the whitewashed narratives we learn in school. 

 

Second, I believe that the lesser-known voices often capture the times better than the famous ones. In fact, the more enduring works are often timeless, which is in conflict with being of the time they were written in, if that makes sense. One man’s “dated” is another man’s “genuine picture of the spirit of the age.” 

 

Third, the voices that fall into neglect are all too often those of women, minorities, and outsiders to the establishment. Their voices matter too. 


In the case of American Humor, it would be accurate to say that it is dated. It was published in 1931, and thus lacks any idea of what would come afterward. It is mostly backwards-look, but from the specific perspective of its time. 

 

It would also be accurate to say that it does in fact capture that time rather well, particularly the viewpoint of what American writing in the 19th century was all about. We may look at that era very differently for a variety of reasons, but that doesn’t mean that we are more “right” than earlier writers. We just see things differently. 

 

Perhaps the best example of this is that, from our vantage point, we can see pretty clearly that America has always had its own culture, and draw a fairly straight line from, say, Washington Irving, through Hemingway and Fitzgerald, to our modern diverse literary scene. But a century ago, there was plenty of debate on whether America had culture at all, or if we were just recycling European stuff, just at lower quality. 

 

Constance Rourke held the opposite view, and this book is, at its core, an argument that there is a unique and valuable American style, and that our humor is unique. 

 

Rourke wrote a variety of books. Her biographies were respected in their day, her literary criticism and biographical sketches for magazines were popular, and her cultural works like this book (which has never gone out of print) influential. She taught at Vassar, and worked on the Index of American Design with the WPA during the Depression. She should be remembered as an important literary figure of her time. 

 

In most summaries of the book you can find, you get the early part of the book, where she describes what she sees as the three quintessential American character types in humor: the Yankee salesman, the frontier backwoodsman, and the blackface minstrel. 

 

However, this is just the starting point, and she gets into a whole lot more than that, including several chapters on American writers, which are fascinating and at times hilarious. She can snark as well as any man, and even when I disagree with her assessments, I have to admit she makes a case for her views. 

 

Also, because she spends a good bit of time on Henry James, and proves to actually understand that his books are full of humor, I can’t help but like her. 

 

I should give fair warning that this book will make a whole lot more sense if you have a working knowledge of 19th century American literature. And not just the big names, but the humorists like Bret Harte (totally underrated) and Artimus Ward. You can still enjoy the book without that, but you will enjoy it much more if you do. And really, many of these lesser lights from the past that Rourke talks about are well worth reading. 

 

The one thing that, to me, seems the most dated about the book is the lack of engagement with non-white authors and humor. Some of this, I presume, is simple ignorance. It wouldn’t be until a few years later that Zora Neale Hurston wrote her book on the African American story tradition, Mules and Men. What Rourke does do is note that the white humorists she writes about often borrowed from African Americans and Native Americans, which, for her time, was pretty progressive of an admission. 

 

At the time the book was being written, of course, African American artistry was taking America by storm. Ragtime and Jazz had gone mainstream, causing much pearl clutching from racist white fundamentalists. The Harlem Renaissance is still one of the greatest flowerings of artistic output in our history, and brought black writers to the attention of white readers. 

 

Rourke was writing mostly about the past, so it is perhaps at least understandable that she missed the important developments of the present. 

 

In any case, Rourke was pretty progressive for her time, so the book seemed to me to be dated rather than offensive in its attitudes. 

 

Rather than try to summarize chapters, I am just going to give a random selection of lines and passages that I thought were interesting and good. 

 

First is a reference to Bronson Alcott as a real-life example of the yankee salesman. I read March recently with a couple of friends, and thus made the connection. 

 

I also liked this line, regarding the influence of Irish immigrants, and their brief time as a stock character in American humor. 

 

Irish immigrants settled in New Hampshire about 1820, bringing with them potatoes and fairies; the potatoes flourished, but the fairies died out. 

 

The Irish also are discussed in the chapter on the backwoodsman. Rourke notes that just as old time music (which evolved into bluegrass and country later) was created by the fusion of African American music and Irish music, the character of the woodsman drew heavily from both traditions. 

 

One more Irish reference caught my eye. 

 

A horn of hard liquor was known in the West as a little of “the creature” or of “the element.” 

 

Any of us children of the 1980s can remember that phrase, right? Crooked Irish politician Honest John in An American Tail offers the socialite Gussie Mouseheimer “a wee drop of the creature,” which is strong enough to burn holes in the floor. (That movie has aged really well, actually…) 

 

Surprisingly, the chapter on minstrelsy was both fascinating and illuminating. Rourke gives a lot of details for performers now mostly forgotten, including where and how they likely got their material.

 

Rice and Emmett can only have borrowed the fables, probably with their tunes. 

 

Which they then mixed with their own compositions, making an amalgam. Rourke notes that the African American stuff was a lot better than what Rice and Emmett invented themselves. 

 

It wasn’t just the obscure artists either. Rourke notes that Stephen Foster borrowed or stole pretty liberally, and his best tunes all came from spirituals that were repurposed. 

 

Songs and poetry also get extended discussions. One of the particularly interesting ones involved a long and digressive musical telling of the story of Pocahantas. It included a pretty pointed condemnation of what Rourke calls “the predatory purpose of the American invaders,” which she quotes a bit of:

 

Grab away

While you may

In this game, luck is all

And the prize

Tempting lies

In the rich City Hall.

Grab away

While you may

Every day there’s a job.

It’s a fact,

By contract

All intact you may rob.

 

In this chapter on the “strollers” - traveling humorists, she also notes that it was part of the spirit of the age. 

 

Other strollers besides those of the stage appeared in this long era, with an expression drawn in similar curves. These were the revivalists, the groups of millennium-seekers, the believers in cults. In a fundamental and not irreverent sense they belonged to the theater; they too followed the arc of romantic feeling; and they moved toward comedy, even toward burlesque. 

 

You think? That is still a hallmark of American religion - it is still a stage act, built on emotion and vibe. And there’s more:

 

Most of the new religious communities created almost overnight in the ‘30s and ‘40s agreed to release mankind from sin, poverty, or mortal care. They all possessed formulas, religious, economic, or social; and they all anticipated conclusions such as the world had never known. Triumph was their note. Biblical proof was adduced to show that the Americans were a chosen people, that the continent - even the Mississippi valley - was the predestined scene for the Second Coming and that the happy thousand years were to begin there. 

 

The more things change…

 

I really enjoyed the chapters on American writers. Chapter 6, for example, covers Emerson, Whitman, Poe, Hawthorne, Melville, and Audubon, pointing out the humor - uniquely American - in their works. 

 

Chapter 7 looks at “Western” writers, from Twain to Harte and others. It also includes an anonymous description of California from the Gold Rush days that may be even more true today. 

 

“One of the most heterogeneous masses that ever existed since the building of the tower of Babel.” 

 

I was also happy to see a discussion of Innocents Abroad, one of the most hilarious books ever written, and, as Rourke notes, one that contains the quintessential American character and humor. 

 

Chapter 8 has a lot about Henry James. Rourke makes a point I hadn’t entirely thought of, that, particularly for his time, James sure featured women as the main characters a lot. Maybe that is one reason I love his books: he writes excellent, nuanced, and complicated female characters, who can be heroes, villains, and most often everything in between. A lot of the women are also the kind that I am attracted to. 

 

Occasionally James pictured the child of nature - fully feminine at last - as in Daisy Miller or Pandora Day, thus following another tradition; but in the main the women with whom he was most deeply engaged took the aloof, the conscious, the slightly studious part.

 

There is also an extended discussion of William Dean Howells, an author that I think should be better known, not just for his books, but for his role in promoting other authors of his time. He is one of the most important names in American literature, but I find few have heard of him these days. You can read about him and his best known book, The Rise of Silas Lapham, in this post. 

 

There is also an entire chapter on poets, featuring one of my all-time favorites, Emily Dickinson. In it, Rourke quotes (among others) an "irreverent" poem that gets to the pithy center of why a certain Evangelical doctrine makes no moral sense. 

 

“Heavenly Father,” take to thee

The supreme iniquity,

Fashioned by thy candid hand

In a moment contraband.

 

Though to trust us seem to us

More respectful - “We are dust.”

We apologize to Thee

For thine own Duplicity.

 

A few more of the authors mentioned: E. A. Robinson, Vachel Lindsey (who Rourke pretty much tears a well deserved new one), Robert Frost (who had yet to write many of his best-known poems), Carl Sandberg, Edgar Lee Masters, Willa Cather, Sinclair Lewis, and Will Rogers. 

 

Overall, an interesting book, and one I am glad I took the time to read.