Source of book: I own this
I have read a number of Steinbeck
books over my lifetime. The Grapes of Wrath pre-dates this blog, but
here are the other ones that I have written about:
Cannery
Row
East
of Eden
Of
Mice and Men (Novel)
Of
Mice and Men (Play)
The
Red Pony
Tortilla
Flat
The Winter of Our Discontent
is Steinbeck’s last novel, and one that is often overlooked when listing his
works. For whatever reason, it was never as popular or respected as his earlier
novels.
While as a general rule, I think
it is a bit silly to worry about spoiling books that are older than I am, this
is one case where I will give a spoiler warning. I am going to have to discuss
plot points from late in the book in this post, but will give a warning in case
the reader wishes to stop in order to go read the book.
Astute readers will recognize the
source of the title, from the opening lines of Shakespeare’s play about
Machiavellian power games, Richard
III.
Now is the winter of our discontent
Made glorious summer by this sun of York
The line itself doesn’t appear in
the book until near the end, but its use in the title should give some clues
about the book itself.
The book will center around an
anti-hero, who, much like (the fictional) Richard III, decides to take
advantage of circumstances to elevate and enrich himself, unfortunately at the
expense of others. And, like with Shakespeare’s anti-hero, success doesn’t
bring happiness, but only destruction.
That said, unlike Richard III,
Ethan Allen Hawley isn’t a pure villain, not by half. He is more like a Greek
tragic hero, damned by the fates, caught up in an amoral capitalist game that
rewards vice and punishes virtue.
It is a testament to Steinbeck’s
writing that as much as I was horrified by the depths to which Ethan sunk by
the end of the book, I also had a lot of sympathy for him, and a feeling that
the moral issues weren’t nearly as black and white as I wanted to think. (I’ll
talk more about them in the section with spoilers.)
The book is seriously cynical and
bitter, but also an incredible critique of the immoral heart of capitalism; an
uncomfortable examination of the complexities of race, class, and immigration;
and a question about who “deserves” success in society and economy.
Consider it a very different book
from The Grapes of Wrath in that sense. You can’t completely like anyone
in this book, except maybe Ethan’s daughter. Everyone else is to some degree or
another tainted by the society they live in.
Ethan is from a formerly
aristocratic East Coast family. His ancestors were whalers, before becoming
store owners. However, his father managed to squander the fortune, leaving
Ethan working as an underpaid clerk in the grocery store his family used to own.
To make things worse, his own
family resents their lowered social status, and blame Ethan for lacking
ambition.
As we gradually learn, one of the
reasons Ethan’s father lost the fortune was through some devious insider
dealings from the bank owner, Mr. Baker, which probably included burning a ship
for the insurance money, thus putting the losses mostly on Ethan’s father.
The new owner of the grocery
store, Mr. Marullo, is an Italian immigrant, who has risen from poverty through
a combination of hard work and ruthless business acumen. And Ethan’s low wages
are one of the ways he retains profitability. So he is both admirable and an
oppressor at the same time. But he too is ground in the wheels of capitalist
profit-seeking.
Ethan served in World War Two, as
did his family friend, another former aristocrat, Danny, who has turned to
alcohol to cope with his PTSD. All that Danny has left is the old family
property, which he thinks is worthless except for pride.
Meanwhile, Ethan’s wife’s best
friend, Margie, is trying to seduce him, while using her fortune telling skills
to encourage him to take a financial risk to better his fortunes.
I should mention the unusual way
the book is written. It is in two parts, and at the beginning of the two parts,
the chapters are in third person, although mostly from Ethan’s point of view.
Then the book switches to first person. I’m not entirely sure why Steinbeck
does this.
At this point, I think I have to
stop before giving spoilers. So much of what happens in the book is important
to my thoughts about it. Hence, stop here if you haven’t read the book, and
come back later.
***
Ethan starts off the book as
perhaps even a bit too upright for his own good. He turns down a chance at a
bit of a kickback from a supplier. He brushes off the banker’s suggestion that
he raid his wife’s modest inheritance to invest in a project in the expanding
and gentrifying Sag Harbor. He tries to do the right thing whenever he
can.
But, as the book goes along, he
succumbs to temptation, and eventually commits two pretty lousy acts, although,
as I had to admit, there was a level of moral ambiguity present.
Through listening and paying
attention, Ethan comes to realize two things. First, Marullo is an undocumented
immigrant, and thus vulnerable to deportation. (Hey, this book feels
timely…)
The second is that the land Danny
owns is coveted by developers (including Mr. Baker) as the only viable site for
an airport.
Suddenly, Ethan has two options
available that just require a bit of ethical contortion. He also decides on a
third: to gain some operating capital, he will use his friend Joey’s (the bank
clerk) inside information to pull off a bank heist.
The first two are pretty
successful. An anonymous tip leads to Marullo’s arrest, and leverage to
purchase the store at a discount. Ethan borrows a bit of his wife’s inheritance
and gives it to Danny, with the express instructions that he should check himself
into rehab. Knowing full well that Danny will (and does) promptly drink himself
to death instead. Oh, and Ethan knows that Danny, having no family left, has
left the property to Ethan’s wife.
The third, however, ends up
interrupted, so Ethan never does rob the bank.
Everything ends up great for him
on the surface. He gets a bit of long-awaited revenge on Baker and Marullo, is
given the store by Marullo (who believes Ethan is honest), and is able to
insist on a controlling interest in the development of the airport.
Conscience is a bitch, though, and
Ethan isn’t able to live with himself. Compounding this is that his son wins an
essay contest by ripping off speeches from past statesmen. This is only found
out when Ethan’s daughter blows the whistle, thus getting her revenge on her
insufferable older brother.
So, here is where things get a bit
morally ambiguous.
Ethan would prefer that Danny
actually get help. And, he does essentially offer that help. Meanwhile, Baker
has tried to trick Danny into selling the property, so Ethan is essentially
protecting Danny’s interest. In fact, he was willing that Danny should get the
profits, except that Danny is so removed from reality that he refuses to even
consider selling.
If not for the fact that Ethan
knows full well that Danny will drink himself to death - indeed, fully intends
to - Ethan’s actions might be considered moral. And even then, he merely
hastens the inevitable. Danny will do himself in fairly soon anyway, and in the
meantime, Ethan has just taken an advantage that may well have gone to Baker
instead.
And I shed zero tears that Baker
gets the short straw. He has lived his life by the immoral demands of profit,
and has not hesitated to ruin good men to make money. So anything he loses is
fine by me. If only Danny hadn’t had to die.
The other case is tougher. Marullo
isn’t an admirable character. He is ruthless in his business dealings, putting
competitors out of business. He cuts wages to the bare bone. He is
condescending in his treatment of Ethan.
On the other hand, deportation of
someone who has lived in the country for decades, built a business, and been a
member of society, is immoral in itself. This is the evil of our immigration
laws - both the one from 1920 that excluded Jews, Italians, Greeks, and Asians;
and our current one that excludes most non-white immigrants from an
opportunity to immigrate legally.
Ethan’s revenge on his employer is
disproportionate. But it also reveals racist and classist beliefs. Part of why
Ethan seethes about his lowly clerk position is that his family used to be
something. He sees himself, not as working class, but as a member of the
aristocracy.
And worse yet, his family store is
owned by a “dago,” a “wop,” one of those dirty immigrants that wouldn’t even be
considered “white” for another decade or two.
And yet, Ethan still has a
conscience. It bothers him that, rather than just getting a good deal on the
store, he is given it because Marullo mistakenly believes Ethan is honest and
upright. Kind of the Horatio Alger karma thing.
But this is the problem. Being
honest is a serious disadvantage in our capitalist, profit-worshipping system.
It is possible, at least
sometimes, to do okay on honesty and reputation. But to actually become rich,
you have to be ruthless, and that means harming other people on the way up. Or
at least looking the other way while the system harms them.
To get into all the ways this book
looks at that idea would take too much space. I do, however, want to share a
number of excellent lines.
I’ll start with the dedication,
which is pretty spot on.
Readers seeking to identify the fictional people and places
here described would do better to inspect their own communities and search
their own hearts, for this book is about a large part of America today.
There are many passages lovingly
describing the grocery store.
The store was greeny from the drawn shades over the big front
windows. Again shelves to the ceiling, filled neatly with gleaming canned and
glassed foods, a library for the stomach.
This line reminds me so much of my
own wife, who can go from crawling into bed to dead out in under 10 seconds.
Maybe it is those decades of working night shift.
My wife, Mary, goes to her sleep the way you would close the
door of a closet. So many times I have watched her with envy. Her lovely body
squirms a moment as though she fitted herself into a cocoon. She sighs once and
at the end of it her eyes close and her lips, untroubled, fall into that wise
and remote smile of the ancient Greek gods.
In contrast to Mary, whose inner
life we never really know, is Ethan, who struggles to sleep, and who is always
inside his own head, something I certainly understand.
“Ethan, you’re talking in your mind. I don’t know what it’s
about but it’s loud. Stop thinking, Ethan.”
Another line is about Ethan’s
ancestors, who often freelanced a bit on the sea, shall we say.
They successfully combined piracy and puritanism, which aren’t
so unalike when you come right down to it. Both had a strong dislike for
opposition and both had a roving eye for other people’s property.
And one of many about money, both
as a thing, and as an idea encompassing the profit motive, and also in light of
the dubious origins of his own family’s money.
Money not only has no heart but no honor nor any memory.
Money is respectable automatically if you keep it a while.
Thus the money from piracy becomes
“old money” and thus status, if you wait long enough.
This one, about stories, rings
true as well.
A man who tells secrets or stories must think of who is
hearing or reading, for a story has as many versions as it has readers.
Everyone takes what he wants or can from it and thus changes it to his measure.
Some pick out parts and reject the rest, some strain the story through their
mesh of prejudice, some paint it with their own delight. A story must have some
points of contact with the reader to make him feel at home in it. Only then can
he accept wonders.
This applies double for sacred
texts, of course.
No one wants advice - only corroboration.
And the hits keep on coming. How
about this insight, which seems applicable to MAGA in our time?
When a condition or a problem becomes too great, humans have
the protection of not thinking about it. But it goes inward and minces up with
a lot of other things already there and what comes out is discontent and
uneasiness, guilt and a compulsion to get something - anything - before it is
all gone.
There is also a paragraph about
the Campbellites, one branch of which became the Church of Christ, with its ban
on musical instruments for worship. (One of our neighbors as a kid was a
minister at a small Church of Christ - he was a good man, whatever our
theological differences.) Back in the day, another branch got heavily into the
predictions of Christ’s return. I found this paragraph rather intriguing.
I remember a story Aunt Deborah told me long ago. Early in
the last century some of my people were Campbellites. Aunt Deborah was a child
then, but she remembered how the end of the world was coming at a certain time.
Her parents gave everything away, everything they owned but the bed sheets.
Those they put on and at the predicted time they went to the hills to meet the
End of the World. Dressed in sheets, hundreds of people prayed and sang. The
night came and they sang louder and danced and as it got near time there was a
shooting star, she said, and everybody screamed. She could still remember the
screaming. Like wolves, she said, like hyenas, although she had never heard a
hyena. Then the moment came. White-dressed men and women and children held
their breaths. The moment went on and on. The children got blue in the face -
and then it passed. It was done and they were cheated out of their destruction.
In the dawn they crept down the hill and tried to get back the clothes they had
given away, and the pots and pans and their ox and their ass. And I remember
knowing how bad they must have felt.
There is still a strain of this in
the American
Religion. “Cheated out of their destruction” sums it up pretty well.
Another passage analyzes the way
that corruption is part of the social fabric to the degree that we don’t
recognize it.
The men who governed it, politically, morally, economically,
had so long continued that their ways were set. The Town Manager, the council,
the judges, the police were eternal. The Town Manager sold equipment to the
township, and the judges fixed traffic tickets as they had for so long that
they did not remember it as illegal practice - at least the books said it was.
Being normal men, they surely did not consider it immoral. All men are moral.
Only their neighbors are not.
One of the best chapters in the
book is Margie’s unsuccessful attempt at seduction of Ethan. Wherever Ethan’s
weaknesses are, they do not lie in that direction.
Margie’s back story ties in with
the themes of the book. When she divorced her first husband, she was awarded
alimony, which she has lived off of for decades. However, his health is
failing, and when he dies, she will be out of luck, so finding another man to
support her is necessary.
But she in a way respects Ethan
too much to play the game, and instead offers too much information about
herself, perhaps in an effort to scare him off. Her analysis of most men may
explain her actions.
Margie had known many men, most of them guilty, wounded
in their vanity, or despairing, so that she had developed a contempt for her
quarry as a professional hunter of vermin does. It was easy to move such men
through their fears and vanities. They ached so to be fooled that she no longer
felt triumph - only a kind of disgusted pity.
This too reminds me a bit of MAGA
- Trump plays on the same fears and vanities as Margie, but he gets played in
turn by smarter operators like Putin.
Another one regarding Margie, who
I think is an excellent character.
Margie liked Mary Hawley very much and she had little
sympathy and no pity for her. Misfortune is a fact of nature acceptable to
women, especially when it falls on other women.
Oh, do I know women like this.
Hell yes.
Margie also turned down Mr. Baker
on an occasion, and the reason is interesting.
Baker had made a grammatically correct but obscure pass at
her once. Mr. Baker was Mr. Money. Sure he had a wife, but Margie knew the
Bakers of this world. They could always raise a moral reason for doing what
they wanted to do anyway. She was glad she had turned him down. It left him
still in the book.
Ethan spends a lot of time
thinking, as I mentioned, and we get his thoughts. This one is another musing
on business, and the amorality of the profit motive.
What are morals? Are they simply words? Was it honorable to
assess my father’s weakness, which was a generous mind and the ill-founded
dream that other men were equally generous? No, it was simply good business to
dig the pit for him. He fell into it himself. No one pushed him. Was it immoral
to strip him when he was down? Apparently not.
And more:
If it succeeded, they would be thought not crooked but
clever. And if a factor they had overlooked moved in, would that be immoral or
dishonorable? I think that would depend on whether or not it was
successful…Strength and success - they are above morality, above criticism. It
seems then, that it is not what you do, but how you do it and what you call it.
Is there a check in men, deep in them, that stops or punishes? There doesn’t
seem to be. The only punishment is for failure.
This seems to be the philosophy of
MAGA, and indeed the Republican party. It is failing not because of how deeply
immoral and unethical it is, but because it is incompetent and failing. This is
to me and many others deeply troubling. It seems Steinbeck may be right, that
most people lack a basic conscience that would check their behavior.
Ethan ties all this back to the
war, in that “morality” for a soldier is simple: kill on command. The rest of
it doesn’t matter.
He could devote his full capacity, untwisted by conflicting
thought and feeling, to the job he had to do - the killing of men. He was the
best officer I ever knew. I asked his permission to use his method and he gave
it to me. When he was killed, all I could think was that his had been a good
and effective life. He had taken his pleasure, savored his love, and paid his
debts, and how many people even approached that?
I’ll end with a line that Ethan
delivers to Mr. Baker after revealing that he essentially has gone behind his
back to seize the opportunity afforded by Danny’s land.
“You’ll feel better, sir, when you have got used to the fact
that I am not a pleasant fool.”
Again, I have zero sympathy for
Baker: he has lived his life profiting off the misery and misfortune of others,
so it is high time someone got the better of him.
The book is definitely cynical,
and more than a bit bitter. Perhaps that didn’t much match the mood of 1961,
with JFK recently elected. But it seems to fit our own times all too
well.
As always, I found Steinbeck’s
writing to be compelling, even in a book as unpleasant at its emotional core as
this one. It’s worth a read.