Thursday, October 21, 2021

Absolute Truth Versus Absolute Authority

 

This post has been in my head for quite a long time. The genesis of it was an epiphany I had years ago, even before the Trump Era, when I realized that it was literally impossible to discuss most issues with religious fundamentalists. Increasingly, this came to be true, not just of true Fundies, but for nearly all Evangelicals, and virtually all Republicans. It was particularly frustrating when it happened with people that I used to love and respect and had previously found to be rational people. 

 

It kind of came to head in a series of conversations with people close to me, where they would eventually say something like, “we can’t even seem to talk about anything anymore.” And they were right. But not for the reasons they thought. 

 

In order for two people to have a rational, productive conversation, they have to have some common reference points. When that is the case, discussions can still lead to significant disagreements, but at least the argument can occur on common ground. As a benefit of this, often disagreements can be resolved by finding one commonality that can bridge the differences. 

 

There are a number of points of commonality that have generally applied between human beings. One is common goals. In many cases, humans have common goals, even if they disagree on how to accomplish them. I want my kids to grow up safe, healthy, and happy, for example. And so do most parents. This can be a point of commonality, but has become a point of contention in our times. 

 

The reason is simple: some of us expand “I want what is best for my children” to encompass “I want what is best for all of our children.” But others limit “best for my children” and don’t give a flying fuck about “other people’s children.” This is literally how we get the response to desperate parents sending their kids over the border by themselves turning out to be (for white right wingers) “send them all back, and who cares if they die?” 

 

That leads to a second traditional commonality: common morals, or common empathy. I think we used to have these to a greater extent, but, the American Right, and particularly white evangelicals have shifted dramatically on this, and I find that we do not have actual common morality. See the border issue above. Or, “should people die because they can’t afford healthcare?” 

 

So, if you can’t appeal to a common morality, empathy, or goals, what is left? 

 

At the most fundamental level, it would seem that we could at least appeal to facts. To some common understanding of truth. 

 

And that is what this post is about. Because the fundamental truth that I learned in the last decade is this:

 

Evangelicals do not believe in absolute truth. 

 

Yes, I said it. 

 

For all the decades of indoctrination, for all the slanderous claims about atheists, it turns out that the ones who actually do not believe in absolute truth are the ones who claim loudly that they and they alone know truth. 

 

I find it fascinating that, generally speaking, atheists freely embrace the idea of absolute truth. (Which is contrary to the bullshit I was taught.) Most people - particularly in practice - accept the idea of absolute truth. It really is just one group - conservative religious people, particularly white Evangelicals - that resist it. 

 

But they do believe in AN absolute: Absolute Authority.

 

There is a huge difference. And this difference is why we cannot talk about things anymore. 

 

Without further ado, let me do a compare and contrast with these two concepts:

 


 

***


1. Absolute Truth: Absolute Truth Exists as a Reality

 

In this worldview (for lack of a less triggering term), absolute truth exists. There are fundamental truths and realities that govern our universe. Gravity exists (although our understanding of what it is has changed), and we can describe its effects in mathematical ways. Germ theory explains many diseases - and viruses are not a fantasy. Carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere affect climate. (Widely understood since the 18th Century.) Fossil evidence tells a story of the past. And that is just a very small sampling of accepted absolute truth. 

 

Most of us - in practice - live our lives accordingly. We believe in practice that truth is absolute, and we can count on it being true and continuing to be true. We accept that truth doesn’t care whether we believe it or not - it is true even if everyone doubts it. 

 

Absolute Authority: Truth is what the Absolute Authority says it is.

 

This is, again, a huge difference. Truth isn’t an ultimate reality in itself, but rather a fiat declaration by an absolute authority. For Evangelicals, this could be expressed as “truth is what God says is true.” And, as a corollary, they, speaking for God, tell you what truth is. 



2. Absolute truth: Truth is out there to be discovered

 

The process of finding truth, for those of us who believe in absolute truth, is a process of discovery. We observe, we learn, we explore. Science is one tool that assists us in doing this. And not just the “hard” sciences, but disciplines such as economics, sociology, psychology, and even, in some cases, mysticism, music, and poetry. These are different ways of approaching the truth that exists using all of our human abilities. 

 

The quest for truth is never-ending, because we will never know everything, understand perfectly, simply because truth is too big to contain in our human minds. But we can discover more, understand better, and tap into that limitless truth that exists. 

 

Absolute authority: Truth has been revealed

 

Who needs to discover truth? We already know truth, because our preferred authority already told us what that truth is. “Discovering” truth is merely looking to the authority to be told what the truth is. The claim is, of course, that god himself has revealed truth to them, and since god is infallible, so are they. But in reality, what they mean is that god has “revealed” truth to them by what ancient people wrote down and what their modern authorities say those ancient writings mean. It all comes down to human authority in the end. God has revealed the “truth” to their preferred authorities. 



3. Absolute truth: While truth is absolute, our ability to see and understand it is imperfect

 

This is a significant reason that believers in Absolute Authority claim that believers in Absolute Truth do not in fact believe in truth. Because we tend to change our minds given better information or a more complete understanding, we are viewed as being “relativists.” But in fact, because we believe in absolute truth, but not in our own abilities to always see and understand perfectly. Hence, we never stop the quest for truth - we try to see better, and understand better, and adjust our beliefs to better align with truth as we do. 

 

Absolute authority: We know the truth because it was revealed to us

 

See above. Believers in Absolute Authority already see perfectly and understand perfectly, because the authority has told them the truth in perfect and perfectly understood form. 



4. Absolute truth: Anyone can discover the truth

 

By “anyone,” what I mean is this: there is no tribal limitation to who can discover and know truth. No theological, racial, or national limitations. Anyone willing to search for truth can find it, provided they have an open mind and the skills necessary to understand and explore truth in a given area. In practice, this means that believers in Absolute Truth expect that people of varying religions, ethnicities, income level, nationality, and gender to be able to understand and find truth. The question is not “who” but “is it true.” This is one reason that believers in Absolute Truth read broadly, and outside of their own race, religion, and nationality. Truth can be found there too, because there are humans worldwide who seek and discover truth. 

 

Absolute authority: Truth can only be known by those with the right theology (and politics)

 

I wrote about this more extensively in my post on Presuppositionalism. Believers in Absolute Authority have to have a way of determining who the authority is, after all. And this is done by looking at whether the potential authority already believes the “right” things - theologically or politically. 

 

As one might expect, this leads to circular reasoning. Truth is what the authority says, and we believe the authority because he says what we already believe. 

 

This is why, just to give an example, public health experts are disbelieved regarding Covid-19, but crackpot charlatans pushing fake cures are believed. The first are perceived as being “liberals” or “atheists” or otherwise outside of the theological orthodoxy. (And also, they disagreed with the Orange Messiah.) Whereas the charlatans speak the same theological and political language. 



5. Absolute Truth: No person or group has a monopoly on the truth

 

As Aquinas once said, “All truth is God’s truth.” The corollary to the above is that since anyone can discover and understand truth, no one group has a monopoly on truth. Because of this, cross-tribal dialogue is crucial to sharing and refining our understanding of truth. 

 

Absolute authority: Only our group owns the truth. Everyone else is wrong until they agree with us.

 

This is literally the way white Evangelicals think. They alone have god’s truth, and everyone else is wrong until they agree entirely with white Evangelicals. Hence, non-white theologians are wrong until they agree with the enslaving and slavery defending white theologians of the 19th Century that white Evangelicals have decided are their authorities. Other religions are clearly wrong. And scientists who do not believe the theological orthodoxy are wrong by definition. 

 

Unsurprisingly, this leads to disregard of all voices outside of a very white, very male, very Western hegemony. And also, only right-wing political beliefs can be true. Because only their tribe has truth. 



6. Absolute Truth: Experts and expertise matter

 

Those who do not think through this issue tend to claim that a reliance on experts and expertise contradicts #4 above. But this is a shallow analysis. Believers in Absolute Truth know that these two ideas are actually complementary and necessary for each other. 

 

Here is an analogy: Not long ago, there was a widespread belief in the (mostly male) Classical Music world that women lacked the physical ability to be world-class brass players. Abbie Conant blew away that prejudice. In essence, she made it obvious that anyone (male or female) could be a world-class brass player. But you can’t just take a random person off the street (male or female) and hand them a trombone and expect them to play it. Heck, I’m a professional violinist, and I would be a hopeless mess with a trombone. Anyone can be a trombonist. But it takes years of training and practice.

 

Likewise for discovering and understanding truth in many areas of life. Scientific exploration takes years of training and practice, and expertise matters. Likewise in other disciplines such as economics, sociology, medicine, public health, and many of the areas involving political decisions. An average person off the street is not qualified to opine about whether Critical Race Theory helps explain entrenched inequality (and most likely couldn’t define CRT if their life depended on it.) Likewise for climate change, or OSHA regulations, or vaccine efficacy. These are areas where we need trained experts who work with and understand how to use the relevant data. 

 

(This doesn’t mean that average people shouldn’t vote: democracy is a different issue from how we determine truth.)  

 

Believers in Absolute Truth look to those who devote their lives to discovering truth using their training and expertise as sources of truth. Sure, skepticism and questioning are part of the process - but expertise does matter. 

 

Absolute authority: Only theology and tribe matter. 

 

You can see this in action throughout our current political culture. For the Right Wing, only tribal affiliation matters. For white Evangelicals, only theology and tribal affiliation matter. Expertise is distrusted, because it tends to contradict their political and theological ideologies, which are, bluntly put, not true. 



7. Absolute Truth: Truth is discovered by observation, experiment, and experience

 

To a significant degree, if you believe in Absolute Truth as something to be discovered, you need a way of thinking and acting that leads to discovery and understanding of that truth. 

 

While the scientific method is not the end-all of methods, it is necessary for the discovery of certain kinds of truth, and helpful for many others. 

 

In all cases, discovery of truth requires observation. Mere thinking in the abstract is divorced from all reality, and depends so much on where one starts. Thus, thought is a useful part of the process, but it is not the entire process. Observation of the world around us, of others, of causes and effects, is where the search for truth starts. 

 

Experimentation is the way that we test our ideas. An observation leads to a hypothesis about what is happening, experimentation can help determine the truth. Furthermore, experimentation can and does lead us to discover what works and what doesn’t. 

 

These experiences help shed light on reality and truth. Ultimately, being open to experience - and the experiences of others, who may have different experiences that also shed light on truth - leads to a better understanding of truth. 

 

Absolute authority: truth is delivered from on high, and is discovered through theology

 

To a degree, this can be traced in the Western tradition to Plato and Aristotle, who preferred abstract thinking to experimentation. (Although, to be fair, Aristotle also observed nature and documented an incredible amount.) 

 

This becomes toxic when one believes that truth is determined by thinking hard about theology. To give a nasty example, Bill Gothard’s cult is based on the idea that truth is reached by a hyper-literal approach to the Bible, including trying to re-create the cultural preferences of the past, particularly gender hierarchies. 

 

Observation, experimentation, and experience are looked at as anathema - particularly if they contradict the dogma and ideology. 



8. Absolute Truth: We can and should change our minds when we get more accurate information and understanding of truth

 

This is actually a core belief for those of us who believe in Absolute Truth. Because we realize that we understand imperfectly, we know that we will need to change our minds when we understand better. (See #3 above.) 

 

One could quote Saint Paul here:

 

For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when completeness comes, what is in part disappears. When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me. For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.

 

As humans, we are always going to have an incomplete understanding, but we can increasingly have a better understanding. 

 

Isaac Asimov, the late great science and science fiction writer, wrote an amazing essay entitled “The Relativity of Wrong.” I highly recommend it. An imperfect understanding doesn’t invalidate that understanding completely. And changing one’s mind when better information is discovered isn’t a sign of “relativism,” but actually an acknowledgement that a constant search for better knowledge and understanding of Absolute Truth is not only possible, but necessary. 

 

Absolute authority: We were always right (even when we change our minds...but don’t talk about that.) 

 

This would crack me up, if it weren’t for the deadly serious consequences of this way of thinking. White Evangelicals deny that they have changed. They deny that theology has changed over the millennia. They deny that many of their political positions are younger than I am. So, they engage in historical revisionism, claiming that “we have always been at war with Eastasia.” That way, they can claim that they have never changed, that their beliefs have never changed, and that truth and understanding never change. 

 

But actually, what has happened is that the authority has told them what they should accept as truth. Since the idea of Absolute Authority hasn’t changed, they can simply accept the new “truth” as if it always was that way, because their preferred authority tells them so. (See: Trump, Donald, for endless examples of this.) 



9. Absolute Truth: We can learn from the ideas of the past, but we should be open to learn

 

It might come as a surprise to many believers in Absolute Authority that those of us who believe in Absolute Truth actually know the past and read writers from the past a hell of a lot more than they do. 

 

Actually, our knowledge of history and past ideas inform our current understandings of truth. What people thought in the past is relevant - great thinkers often have insights regardless of when they lived. And also, knowledge of truth doesn’t magically appear. As Newton said, “If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants.” The discovery and understanding of Absolute Truth is a process that is ongoing, and builds on what others have learned. 

 

That said, thinkers of the past have been wrong, sometimes badly. Evaluating their ideas means comparing them to later discoveries and other ideas. In many cases, this also means evaluating their prejudices and the prejudices of their time. (In fact, one of the major changes in how we approach truth in the last few decades has been acknowledging that we need more diversity in our voices - you cannot understand everything about our world without including women, non-whites, and LGBTQ people, for example.) 

 

Thus, the Absolute Truth approach to the past is not to disregard it, but to learn it and evaluate it, taking what turns out to be true and discarding what is not. It is respect, but not worship. 

 

Absolute authority: Truth was revealed in the past, and any changes are heresy. 

 

This is one of the bizarre things about talking with people who believe in Absolute Authority. Whatever authority they claim to follow is typically located in the past, whether ancient or modern - but far enough past that it cannot be questioned. And often this “past” is a myth anyway, such as the myth of the Antebellum South as the most perfect “christian” society. (See: Wilson, Doug)

 

I also should mention that generally, those who believe in Absolute Authority tend to be fairly ignorant of the past, of past ideas. And they have rarely actually read the old books they claim to follow, and are unaware of the scholarship surrounding those books. The past exists as an authority, not as the messy reality human history always is. 

 

Thus, the past is worshipped as an idol, burnished by their preferred legends, and used as a sword against anyone who argues for change from their beliefs about the past. 

 

 

10: Absolute Truth: Truth is best discovered in community

 

This is the outgrowth of the other ideas. No one person or tribe has a monopoly on the truth. Truth is discovered and understood by an ongoing process. A diversity of voices can counteract biases, including confirmation bias. Expertise matters. Observation, experimentation, and experience help us find and understand truth. 

 

Because of this, more people are better than fewer in searching for truth. Cross-dialogue is crucial. And excluding voices leads to bad results. This idea is what I would call community. The “scientific community” is literally what it says it is. Scientists - better than the rest of us - share within their own community, and research and discovery build on everything else going on. 

 

In fact, this is an example of one of the great American myths: in reality, it isn’t the lone genius who discovers and creates. Rather, it is teams of experts working together. Elon Musk didn’t “invent” a damn thing. He put up his money to hire hundreds of engineers and thousands of craftspeople to build his cars and spaceships. Literally nothing you use these days is the work of a single person. Teamwork is what makes things, designs things, distributes things. 

 

For those of us who believe in Absolute Truth, then, one of the challenges of our globalized world is to expand our idea of “community” to include the entire planet, to bring together people from all over to address our challenges. 

 

On a more focused plane, this means that seeking truth when it comes to political and theological problems requires that we include in our community not merely the dominant social class, but those who are negatively affected by our current economic, political, and social hierarchies. We cannot understand the truth about systemic racism without involving minorities. We cannot understand the truth about the depredations of patriarchy without involving women - particularly those who pay the price so other women can enjoy privilege. We cannot understand human sexuality and gender while excluding sexual and gender minorities. It’s about community.  

 

Absolute authority: Truth is dictated by the hierarchy

 

In contrast, those who believe in Absolute Authority see truth as not found in community but in hierarchy. Those with authority know and dictate the truth. Those lower in the hierarchy are bound to accept the truth as dictated. 

 

And, needless to say, the voices of those who say they are suffering because of the actions of those at the top are definitely not welcome. Hence the opposition to CRT, to use just one example. 

 

 

11. Absolute Truth: The world is complex, and solutions to difficult problems are not simple

 

If you believe in Absolute Truth, it is impossible to escape the conclusion that truth is not simple, it isn’t reduceable to slogans or simple solutions. Just like you can’t design a rocket based on high school-level physics equations (although those are a part of the design), you cannot solve every social issue with simplistic answers. 

 

Not only that, but circumstances differ, and the truth doesn’t look exactly the same in all circumstances. Just a scientific example here: light is a wave. Except when it is a particle. And trying to use the wrong analogy to understand the behavior of light in a given situation just doesn’t work. 

 

Likewise, for other areas of truth: we approach truth using analogies, not exact mathematical ideas, so solving problems means finding how truth looks in that situation and acting accordingly. And, of course, experimenting and observing the results, so that the approach can be changed if it isn’t working. 

 

Absolute Authority: We know the simple solutions to every problem

 

Oh god, this is talking to Right Wingers regarding social problems. Or talking with white Evangelicals about nearly everything. There is always a simple solution to be found somewhere in their dogma, and the fact that it isn’t working and has never worked is irrelevant. The authority has dictated the solution, so it must work. (It can’t be Galen who is wrong, it must be the corpse.) The dogma and ideology is always right, reality be damned! And the solutions are always simple and simplistic. “Well, of minorities would just become Christians (meaning, with white theology), they wouldn’t be poor.” “Just take ivermectin for Covid.” “Tax cuts for the rich will solve all our problems.” 

 

 

12. Absolute Truth: While Truth is absolute, applications are not universal prescriptions

 

Related to #11. Applications vary. Light can be treated as a wave or a particle, depending on the situation and application. Social problems need solutions that are directed at the particular needs of suffering people. Not all people respond to medications the same way. LGBTQ people don’t need to be made cishet. 18th Century economic theories don’t work for regulation of complex banking systems or global corporations. Poverty isn’t primarily caused by laziness, so moral lecturing like one would give a wealthy, educated person isn’t effective or helpful. 

 

The complexity of the universe and reality require nuanced and flexible approaches. 

 

Absolute Authority: Universal prescriptions (except when they are not.)

 

Hey, dogma is what matters! (Except when it comes to the rich and powerful, who get a hall pass to be as unethical as they want…) 

 

 

13. Absolute Truth: Skeptical of authoritarianism

 

When you believe that Absolute Truth exists, and can be discovered by anyone willing to do so, it is difficult to embrace a person or party that gets to dictate truth. And that is what authoritarianism is at its core: the ability to dictate truth. 

 

Believers in Absolute Truth therefore are skeptical of anyone claiming to have a monopoly on the truth, whether that is a charismatic leader, a totalitarian party, an authoritarian religion, or an ideology. 

 

Absolute Authority: Embraces authoritarianism

 

Believing that truth comes from authority leads naturally to a belief that a strong authority and authoritarianism are desirable. For religious hucksters like Bill Gothard, this is literally the core of their teachings. God established a hierarchy: men above women, parents above children, religious leaders above everyone. God speaks to the authorities, who then share that truth with those below them. Truth is best enforced (and it must be enforced) by authoritarian control. 

 

And this, in my view, is why white Evangelicals fell so hard for Donald Trump. They have been wanting an autocratic authoritarian for a long time. The fact that Trump is the very embodiment of a liar, and lies constantly does not bother them. Because they believe in Absolute Authority, not truth. Trump has become the authority, and what he tells them is by definition the truth. Even, nay, especially when it contradicts reality. Believing the lie is the way they show loyalty to the authority. 

 

I should also note that believers in Absolute Authority do not see disagreement as a different perspective, but as rebellion against authority. Since truth derives from authority, refusal to accept the dictated truth is rebellion, and should be crushed by force. Hence the need for authoritarianism.

 

 

14: Absolute Truth: Tends to admire people based on accomplishments

 

This is something that I have noticed increasingly in the last decade or so. People who believe in Absolute Truth tend to save their admiration for people who have actually accomplished something. So, at the top of the admiration list tends to be people such as, say Einstein, who revolutionized our understanding of the universe. But also people who accomplished things on a far smaller scale. Many of us admire Anthony Fauci not so much for his role as a much-maligned spokesperson for the CDC, but for his underappreciated role in combating the AIDS pandemic and other public health crises. We also tend to admire the “little people,” the ones working behind the scenes that nobody ever knows the names of. Hidden Figures finally brought some of these names to light, but how many more “computers” still are unknown today? And yet they are heroes of the space program every bit as much as charismatic faces such as John Glenn. 

 

The bottom line here is that those who believe in Absolute Truth tend to look to whether a person has earned credibility, has done any actual work, or accomplished anything through their own efforts. 

 

Absolute Authority: Tends to admire people based on charisma

 

Have you ever wondered WHY anyone actually admires or sends money to televangelists? Why Bill Gothard was able to sell millions of people his pricey seminars and materials, and nobody ever asked him to prove his ideas worked? Why a man who inherited his wealth and still ended up bankrupt a half dozen times before some combination of money laundering and reality television resurrected his fortunes is considered a “good businessman” despite being by any objective standards terrible at business? Or, for that matter, why people like my parents still believe “Reaganomics” works, despite 50 years of evidence that it does not?

 

The answer, I believe, lies in the fact that evidence - truth - is secondary to charisma. And, of course, tribal identity. Truth is dictated by authority, authority is determined by tribal identity and charismatic appeal to the tribe. Hence Trump. Hence Reagan. Hence Gothard. Hence televangelists.   

 

 

15. Absolute Truth: Believes empirical evidence

 

Want to know how to change the mind of someone who believes in Absolute Truth? Show your evidence. While humans generally tend to react emotionally, then justify their beliefs later, there are actually plenty who are persuadable. I have, in several cases, changed my mind based on discovery of better evidence. (In fact, one thing you can see as a common theme on this blog, is that I hate being lied to. Show me I was lied to, and present me with evidence, and I will - and have - change my mind.) 

 

When it comes to truth, empirical evidence is the best we have in many cases. And those of us who believe in Absolute Truth generally try to follow the evidence.  

 

Absolute Authority: Believes persuasive charlatans

 

A few acquaintances have been pretty pissed that I have told them straight up that I refuse to engage with Trump voters. The reason for this is that I have discovered that Trump voters have zero interest in engaging with facts or truth. The same largely (although not entirely) goes for white Evangelicals. And for the same reason:

 

Empirical evidence is irrelevant to someone who believes in Absolute Authority. 

 

Since truth is based on authority, and discovery of truth comes from listening to the authority approved by the tribe, the only way to refute Trumpism or Evangelical dogma, or Republican talking points is for the authority to dictate a different truth from on high. (And even then, it doesn’t always work…) The word of the charismatic charlatan always wins over empirical evidence. Every time. 

 

 

16. Absolute Truth: Credibility is earned by telling the truth, and is lost by telling falsehoods

 

Since everyone has to rely to some degree on experts - we cannot all do all the work of experimentation - how does one decide who to believe? For the person who believes in Absolute Truth, credibility is earned by telling the truth consistently. 

 

Why do I trust automotive engineers to design my car? Why do I trust my doctor to diagnose and treat me? Why do I go to the hospital if I am ill? Why do I advise people to consult a lawyer regarding legal issues? 

 

This is how experts work. They build credibility for themselves and their disciplines by consistently telling the truth, and changing when proven to be mistaken. So a believer in Absolute Truth assesses credibility based on past truth-telling. 

 

The flip side of this is that a source that tells falsehoods will lose credibility. One reason I see the Anti-Abortion Industry as completely lacking credibility is that they lie constantly and about everything. And, when I have confronted an Anti-Abortion person with their lies, they double down. Tell lies, and you lose credibility. Even a trusted source can lose their credibility if they cease to tell truth consistently. 

 

Absolute Authority: Credibility is due to tribalist authority, and authorities are believed as truthful despite all evidence to the contrary.

 

“Who you gonna believe, me or your own eyes?” Groucho Marx did this first, but there is an even better scene in An American Tail, unfortunately not online due to copyright crap. 

 

In the case of those who believe in Absolute Authority, credibility comes from tribalist authority, not from a record of truth-telling. In fact, a tribal authority will be believed even as they consistently and proveably lie. Trump is Exhibit A, of course, but he is hardly the first or only example. Because truth is determined by authority, the authority cannot, technically speaking, tell a lie, because whatever that authority says is, by definition, the truth. 

 

 

17. Absolute Truth: Can be persuaded by evidence, logic, and empathy

 

One sign that you are dealing with a person who believes in Absolute Truth is that you can persuade them using evidence, logic, and empathy. In the case of evidence, the way to refute science is better science, not an appeal to authority. Better evidence can be persuasive. A better use of logic can also change the mind of someone who believes in Absolute Truth. Seeing a flaw in one’s thinking will, if one is open minded, to reconsider the results of that flawed thinking process. It certainly has for me - and I have spent my life since my childhood trying to think better. But also, empathy can assist a person who believes in Absolute Truth in reconsidering beliefs. After all, if other people are seeing or experiencing the world differently, perhaps they are seeing or understanding truth from a different perspective, and that perspective can help me get closer to the truth. 

 

Personally, ALL of these three have led me to change my mind. As I grew older, and could read outside of the theological and political bubble, I found that there was better evidence available that challenged my beliefs. One of the side effects of a law school education was that I discovered flaws in my own ways of thinking. I cannot overestimate the difference that law school (the one affiliated with Bill Gothard’s cult no less!) made in my thinking, and the way that that education combined with my later practice of law upended so much of my belief system. 

 

And finally, empathy has changed my mind on so many things. From LGBTQ rights to systemic racism to my theology more generally. It is dangerous to dogma to leave the bubble and talk to people outside of it. 

 

Absolute Authority: Cannot be persuaded by anything

 

This in a nutshell is why I refuse to engage with Trump voters. I have yet to find that they can be persuaded by anything. I mean, if they could, they wouldn’t have voted for Trump in the first place. Their non-white friends would have told them. Empirical evidence would have shown he was grossly unqualified and obviously ignorant every time he opened his mouth. A basic understanding of how fascism works would have revealed his fascist rhetoric. 

 

But those who believe in Absolute Authority cannot be persuaded by anything. Not empirical evidence. Not logic. And certainly not empathy. 

 

I should know. This has been a struggle with family and former friends. But there is nothing you can do, because they already know the truth. They know every goddamn thing there is to know, so listening to others is neither necessary nor desirable. They have their slogans and talking points and are ready to “own the libs.” 

 

And so, I have learned to just disengage. There is zero point in arguing or discussing. 

 

 

18. Absolute Truth: It’s fine to be uncertain

 

I think this one is a good one to end on. Theologian Peter Enns has been instrumental in my own spiritual and moral journey, and one of his great points is that certainty is actually sinful. It is distilled arrogance rather than faith. 

 

For those of us who believe in Absolute Truth, we also are uncertain that we know all of it. The truth is too big for any of us to fully and finally comprehend. Or even remember at the same time. (How much do you remember of what you learned in high school?) 

 

A certain humility comes from realizing that truth is something we search for, discover, and seek to understand, not something that we know in full. Obviously, we “know” some things with a fair degree of certainty. But even then. Case in point: the effects of gravity are fairly well understood, and in the practical sense, I can be as certain that I will fall if I jump as anything. That said, exactly what gravity is is just as uncertain as what light is. We have ways to describe it, predict it; and analogies that let us get our minds around it. But no scientist legitimately thinks humans understand either light or gravity completely. We have our ideas and our models, but we are uncertain as to how accurate they are. 

 

So much more so for the things less amenable to science. For many things, we have uncertainty combined with a determination to do the best we can. And this requires listening, trial and error, and flexibility in coping with a changing world. 

 

It’s okay to admit that you do not know it all. That uncertainty in fact can be an incentive to learn more, understand more - to seek a greater understanding of truth. 

 

Uncertainty is not a threat to a belief in Absolute Truth. Rather, it is expected. 

 

Absolute Authority: Certainty is mandatory

 

Oh heck yes. The point of a belief in Absolute Authority is that you can be certain. This is a comfort to many people. It is so nice to know that you are right and other people are wrong. It’s the same basic orgasmic feeling that self-righteousness in general provides. And, unlike the thrill of discovering truth through hard work, it doesn’t cost any effort. You just purchase it from your authority figure. (Gothard made serious bank doing this, and he isn’t the only one.) 

 

I probably should write a whole post on related idea that a believe in Absolute Authority and the certainty that one knows the truth absolves one from taking responsibility for one’s own actions. It was all god’s fault that I acted like a cruel bigot, right? 

Update: I did eventually write that post. 

The dark side of this, though, is that expressing any doubt, any uncertainty, any deviation from the truth as imposed by the authority, is apostasy, lack of faith, weakness, sin. Certainty is mandatory and non-optional. 

 

***

 

I feel like these 18 points are just the surface of what this topic has to offer, but these are the ones I have been thinking on for several years now. This post expresses my frustration at the lack of commonality I have with family, acquaintances, and others of my former religious and political tribe. But also, it helps to clarify exactly who I enjoy discussions with these days. I don’t agree with everything these friends believe, though. It isn’t primarily an agreement on conclusions, but an agreement on the basic goals of learning and understanding truth, and seeking the common good. 

 

***

 

Earlier this year, I read my first bit of William James, and realized that he is probably the philosopher I feel best reflects my own beliefs. His idea of a diverse and “pluralistic” universe that encompasses everything fits better than either the Platonic “Forms” or the ultra-rigid dualism of Evangelical Fundamentalism I grew up with. His belief in pragmatism - or, as Christ might say, looking at fruit to determine truth - also strikes me as more flexible than an attachment to dogma and ideology. Just for fun, here is a brief quote from A Pluralistic Universe that seems appropriate here. 

 

Hegel was dominated by the notion of a truth that should prove incontrovertable, binding on everyone, and certain, which should be the truth, one, indivisible, eternal, objective, and necessary, to which all our particular thinking must lead as to its consummation. This is the dogmatic ideal, the postulate, uncriticised, undoubted, and unchallenged, of all rationalizers in philosophy. “I have never doubted,” a recent Oxford writer says, that truth is universal and single and timeless, a single content or significance, one and whole and complete. Advance in thinking, in the hegelian universe, has, in short, to proceed by the apodictic words must be rather than may be, which are all that empiricists can use. 

 

 

Tuesday, October 19, 2021

The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Lewis Stevenson

Source of book: Audiobook from the library, but I own this as well.

 

What would an October be without some sort of a spooky story? This classic by Robert Lewis Stevenson has entered the culture to the extent that most everyone knows about the characters. But few have actually read the book, which isn’t exactly the same as the pop culture version. 

 

The basic plot is pretty well known. The respectable Dr. Henry Jekyll has, for reasons that puzzle his friends and acquaintances, taken up with the sinister and unpleasant Mr. Edward Hyde. His friend and lawyer, Gabriel Utterson, tells the story, and seeks to figure out the truth of this mystery. 

 

As we come to learn, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are the same person. Well, mostly the same person. Dr. Jekyll is Dr. Jekyll. But Mr. Hyde is only part of Dr. Jekyll - the evil part. Jekyll’s experiment has been to dissolve the bounds of the elements of his person, and reassemble just part of who he is into a new body, so to speak. Thus, Hyde is much smaller than Jekyll, although he grows a bit during the course of the book - Jekyll feeds the evil part of himself, as it were. 

 

It turns out that the upstanding, respectable Dr. Jekyll has his secrets. While outwardly upright, he has been occasionally indulging certain vices. We never learn what those vices are. Stevenson gives some hints, chief of which is described as follows:

 

And indeed the worst of my faults was a certain impatient gaiety of disposition, such as has made the happiness of many, but such as I found it hard to reconcile with my imperious desire to carry my head high, and wear a more than commonly grave countenance before the public. Hence it came about that I concealed my pleasures; and that when I reached years of reflection, and began to look round me and take stock of my progress and position in the world, I stood already committed to a profound duplicity of me. Many a man would have even blazoned such irregularities as I was guilty of; but from the high views that I had set before me, I regarded and hid them with an almost morbid sense of shame. It was thus rather the exacting nature of my aspirations than any particular degradation in my faults, that made me what I was, and, with even a deeper trench than in the majority of men, severed in me those provinces of good and ill which divide and compound man’s dual nature.

 

My interpretation of this would be that Dr. Jekyll is imprisoned by his class and profession. He must maintain that “respectability” at all costs, or lose his reputation. Perhaps he wanted to go drink and sing at a dive bar. (Victorian Karaoke!) Or hang with the lower classes. Or maybe pick up a girl or a prostitute. In any case, it seems to be something that would scandalize Victorian society - but only when done by someone expected to be “serious.” 

 

That said, one could certainly make the case that Stevenson was too prudish to actually name something sexual, particularly homosexuality, although he seems to go out of his way to be clear that the “vice” wasn’t universally considered bad or shameful. 

 

The problem for Jekyll is how to indulge his vice, while remaining respectable. Hence, the idea of separating out his evil nature, and letting it have its fun in the body of Mr. Hyde, and returning to dormancy afterward. 

 

And this leads to the next problem, which is that Hyde soon went far beyond the benign “vice,” and started getting vicious. He tramples a young girl, then kills a politician. This second, since he is identified, means that Hyde can no longer be out in public. 

 

But then, Jekyll finds that he starts turning into Hyde spontaneously, not through the use of the potion. And then the key ingredient for the potion runs out and cannot be duplicated…

 

The book, of course, saves these revelations for near the end. We modern readers know the truth, but for its original audience, the twist must have been breathtaking. 

 

I first read this book as a kid, and subsequently as an adult, and it reveals new layers every time. (My three younger kids had never read it, although my 17-year-old read and loved it as a small child. She’s the morbid one.) 

 

I was struck this time by several themes which Stevenson handles masterfully. First is the way that the potion becomes like a drug. First, Jekyll uses it for a novel effect - it makes him feel good in a way. But as time goes on, he becomes an addict. He increasingly needs the drug just to feel - or be - normal. And the dosage needs to increase and increase to get the same effect. In an era when laudanum addiction was common among literary sorts (and many others, of course), the progression of opioid addiction was well known and well described. Stevenson makes an allegory of addiction, one might say, progressing from the benign vice of letting one’s hair down, to increasing viciousness and desperation. Anyone who has watched the self-destruction of an addict will find this far too familiar. 

 

Stevenson also explores the complexity of human nature. The longer I live, the more I believe that (with very few exceptions), we are an inseparable blend of good and evil, love and fear, selfishness and altruism. Jekyll, in one of the most moving lines, wonders why he didn’t choose to separate out the “good” portion of himself. It is Utterson, the cynical yet gracious attorney, who seems to understand why: Jekyll spends his life trying to “be” the good side of himself, and thus cannot find a purer goodness to have any benefit. And indeed, modern psychology would say that by repressing everything not socially respectable creates a Hyde in all of us - repression leads to expression, often in a more antisocial way. Thus, Jekyll cannot be spontaneous and free, and his repression leads to violent outbursts by Hyde. 

 

In this way, Stevenson’s book is much deeper and thoughtful than the more moralistic pop culture version. The issue isn’t merely “don’t feed your dark side,” but bleeds over into social hypocrisy, the subconscious, and the long-term damage caused by repression. 

 

And, of course, it’s a great suspense novella. 

 

The audiobook was narrated by Ralph Cosham, who is certainly British enough, and seems well at home with the stylized language of the book. 

 

***

 

Not accurate to the book, but fun nonetheless, is the Loony Tunes take. Like virtually every movie adaptation, it fails to make Hyde smaller, which misses the point that Hyde isn’t the flip-side of Jekyll, but a portion of him. 


Poking around for pictures, I noticed that the movie and older illustrations tend to portray Hyde as animalistic, with big teeth and hair. This is problematic both because it is innaccurate to the book - Hyde is vicious, not a werewolf - but also because Hyde is often given "negro" facial features. If I have to explain that to you, well...

However, I was fascinated to see that plenty of younger artists on DeviantArt had truly great renditions of Jekyll and Hyde, that were much truer to the spirit of the original. In this version, both are younger than the 50ish Jekyll, but are both still "him," and correct as to the age and size difference. The kids are alright, I'd say.  

Monday, October 18, 2021

More Adventures of the Great Brain by John D. Fitzgerald

Source of book: Audiobook from the library, but we own all the Great Brain books.

 

This book is the second in the series - although it was also the book I read first, because we obtained it first. I think the books make most sense if you read them in order, because the backstories of some of the various kids shed light on subsequent events. You can read my thoughts on The Great Brain from 2017 if you like.


 

This book was published in 1969, and the stories themselves are set back in the 1890s, the author’s childhood. Based loosely on the author’s childhood and his conniving elder brother Tom, the adventures are humorous, poignant, and shed a light on the experience of growing up “gentile” in Mormon Utah. 

 

This book picks up where the last one left off. Tom has ostensibly “reformed,” but little brother J.D. (the narrator) and other observant folks know it is temporary. Now that he got that bike for Christmas, he is back to his old ways of tricking J.D. into doing his chores, swindling the other kids, and getting himself into trouble by being too smart for his own good. 

 

As in the previous book, there are humorous stories, but some fairly heavy themes. In perhaps the most pointed episode, Tom decides he wants to prove to his dad (who runs the newspaper) that he is old enough to help out. He borrows the old (smaller) printing press, and sets up shop. He enlists his friends to report, with the idea of printing better news than his dad. 

 

In a stroke of luck, the bank is robbed before the first edition comes out, and Tom comes up with a plan whereby Basil (the Greek immigrant kid) is able to overhear a conversation between the robbers, and thus solve the crime. 

 

The problem is that most of the rest of what Tom prints are the vicious gossip of the townsfolk, and the victims show up to protest and in some cases brawl. Tom learns the hard way that just because something can be printed doesn’t mean it should. (A lot of right wing media sorts could stand to learn this lesson these days - even if slandering immigrants and other minority groups does sell well.) 

 

In other stories, the town dog dies and is given an elaborate funeral, Tom inadvertently starts a panic over “monster” footprints he creates in order to win a bet, tries to prove the non-existence of ghosts, and is given the assignment of “civilizing” a feral girl who has moved to town with her proud and stubborn father. 

 

This last story is the rare one that feels a bit dated. While the stories are very much about a particular time and place, where honor and machismo and frontier justice are taken for granted, Fitzgerald tends to feel progressive even by today’s standards. So, this story felt a bit off in 2021, in a way it didn’t when I was a kid. But let me explain.

 

Dottie’s mother died when she was tiny, and she has lived with her bronco-busting dad ever since. He raises her like a boy, and she feels that his love for her is dependent on her being a son to him. And, after all, they are all each other has. When he is injured and has to take a town job, she has no intention of changing her ways. Thus, Tom (in order to earn back his bike), has to figure out how to “tame.” Dottie. This episode is an example of the fact that Tom, despite his lean toward sociopathy at times, doesn’t have a bad heart, and goes beyond the requirements to make life better for others. Well, when he wants to, and usually when he is getting paid. (In this case, he has a fair point: his reputation with the other boys requires that he not “play with girls” voluntarily. As long as he is being paid for a job, his reputation remains intact.) 

 

The part that seemed a bit dated is the insistence that Dottie conform to expectations of femininity. Again, this is not because Fitzgerald is backwards, but because he accurately portrays the culture. Girls did not wear pants. They did not fight boys. They played with dolls. In this story, I do like that Fitzgerald lets Dottie, even after she is “civilized,” wear pants to ride her horse. I also like that Fitzgerald homes in on the crux of the issue for Dottie: she must please her father no matter what, even if it means subsuming her femininity, and refusing to learn to read. Thus, the task for Tom (and his parents) is to break down both Dottie’s own barriers, and those of her father. And do so in a way that lets them both save face. 

 

I think for me personally, the idea of “feminizing” girls is a sore point. My girls have been raised “like boys” in many ways, not the least of which is that they are every bit as physical as my boys, and wear pants or shorts most of the time. And, of course, my wife has, throughout her life, been subjected to social punishment by Fundies over her refusal to perform “femininity” to their specifications. So yeah, probably a bit of the grating comes from my own issues. Because it really isn’t a bad story, and isn’t about the need to make people conform - it really is about letting people do the right thing without having to feel embarrassed. 

 

In any event, throughout the book, serious issues are handled with grace, humor, and thoughtfulness. I continue to recommend these books to everyone, kid or otherwise. 

 

Wednesday, October 13, 2021

The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes

Source of book: Audiobook from the library

 

I borrowed this earlier in the year, and never got around to listening to it. So, I went back and borrowed it again, and this time made sure I brought it with me on my commute. 


 
This short novel is a fascinating look at the unreliability of memory, and the way we create our self-conception. One might say that it is navel-gazing, but in a good way. It is thoughtful and full of great lines, and the way that the rather self-aware yet totally unreliable narrator wrestles with his own unreliability in the stories he tells to himself is brilliantly done. 

 

There are a number of twists in the plot, which I will try not to spoil more than I have to. Tony is a recently retired Englishman, who starts the book with memories of his high school days, when he was part of a group of four friends that centered around the brilliant yet vaguely troubled Adrian. The boys discuss philosophy with their history teacher, and it is clear that Adrian is far ahead of everyone else. But Adrian never really talks about his family - we know that his mom walked out on him when he was very little, and that he lives with his dad, but Adrian chooses not to go beyond that. 

 

During this time, a classmate commits suicide, apparently because he got a girl pregnant. (This would have been in the 1960s, when, as Tony notes, most people were still living in what was for all practical purposes, the 50s.) Adrian quotes Camus: “There is only one really serious philosophical question, and that is suicide.” This turns out, in retrospect, to be an ominous foreshadowing.

 

The clique breaks up soon after the boys go their own ways for college, although they still see each other occasionally. Tony takes up with a girl named Veronica, who will turn out to be the focus of all that happens afterward. Veronica is, to put it mildly, a deeply unpleasant young woman. She comes from a “posher” family than Tony, and is snobby in a way that I found really off-putting. (Case in point, she pointedly disses Tony’s love for Dvorak and Tchaikovsky, because they are not “serious” composers. That’s unforgivable to me, and I would have dumped her ass forthwith.) Tony, being young and green, is smitten by her at first. He spends a night at her home, where he finds her brother condescending, her father a bit weird, and her mother….well, he doesn’t realize what was going on until literally a lifetime later. 

 

Veronica is also a cock-tease, although that was well in line with the times. What is more bizarre is that after she and Tony break up, then she has sex with him. And then, Tony realizes that he really needs to break up with her for good. The breakup is not, by any standard, a friendly one. 

 

Not too long afterward, Veronica pairs up with Adrian. Tony, rather than act graciously, sends a nasty letter to Adrian wishing him every unhappiness with Veronica. Just how nasty that letter was we do not find out until much later in the book - Veronica kept it, and gives a photocopy to Tony when they (sort of) reconnect as old people. It’s just plain horrible, beyond my own ability to write, honestly. By that time, of course, Tony has regret, and apologizes. 

 

But that is getting ahead of things. 

 

After these blowups, Tony takes a trip to backpack across the US, hooks up with a girl who is clear it is temporary, and comes home to find out that Adrian has committed suicide. 

 

Yeah, that is pretty dramatic, and Adrian’s suicide note gives a lot of philosophy, but no indication whatsoever as to what triggered it. 

 

At that point, the book quickly describes the next 40 years. Tony gets a boring job (which is what he wanted), marries a low-drama woman, Margaret, who ends up leaving him for a less boring man. He has a daughter, and a pair of grandkids. Margaret and Tony remain friends, meeting occasionally for tea, and Tony has, in his own view, an unexceptional life - which is what he wanted. As Tony puts it, he “had wanted life not to bother me too much, and had succeeded.” That’s his personality. 

 

So far, this is only the first third of the book. The events that rock Tony’s world start with something out of the blue. Veronica’s mother has died, and left him a peculiar bequest: 500 pounds, and Adrian’s diary. Except that Tony never actually receives the diary, because Veronica has taken it, and refuses to turn it over. So, Tony goes in search of Veronica, and as much of the truth as he can find. 

 

The revelations that follow are slowly unfolded throughout the rest of the book, and even then, we never learn everything. Tony has to piece things together from small scraps and hints, and in the end, learns more about himself than anything. 

 

Veronica hasn’t changed much in 40 years, of course. She finally tells Tony, “You just don’t get it. You never have, and you never will.” Which is grossly unfair, considering that she refuses to offer information, and somehow expects Tony to have grasped everything based on their short relationship, and his one visit to her home. 

 

Because I listened while driving, I didn’t write down all the great quotes, so I am stuck with those I could find to confirm. One of those is Tony’s musing that at some point in our lives - maybe in our 20s? - our characters become set. 

 

“And after that, we’re just stuck with what we’ve got. We’re on our own. If so, that would explain a lot of lives, wouldn’t it? And also — if this isn’t too grand a word — our tragedy.”

 

He also has ceased to be entirely satisfied with his own character, and the way it has determined his life. He uses the “we” here, perhaps to include Margaret, but really, he means himself.

 

“We thought we were being mature when we were only being safe. We imagined we were being responsible but were only being cowardly. What we called realism turned out to be a way of avoiding things rather than facing them.”

 

I also liked the discussion with the history teacher, and the way that Tony never truly stops thinking about it. Adrian defines history as “that certainty produced at the point where the imperfections of memory meet the inadequacies of documentation." But Tony later wonders whether history consists of the lies of the victors, the self-delusions of the defeated, (as the teacher notes) or, as he comes to believe, "the memories of the survivors, most of whom are neither victorious nor defeated." That’s pretty dang good, and it really stuck with me. The unreliable memories of the survivors, most of whom are neither victorious nor defeated. That’s also a good way to describe the book itself.

 

Although the description might make it sound so, this is not a bleak book - it’s achingly sad in some ways, but in the ways that life itself is achingly sad. It is very British in the way that it feels emotionally self-contained, and all the more penetrating because of that. 

 

The Sense of an Ending is probably not for everyone, but I liked it. It is a bit different from the other modern books I have read lately, and so made a nice contrast. Barnes’ writing is delicious and unhurried, yet the book feels just the right length. 

 

The audiobook was narrated by Richard Morant, who did a fine job. It made for a very enjoyable experience. 

 

***

 

This book should not be mistaken for The Sense of an Ending by Frank Kermode. That book is non-fiction, and addresses the way apocalyptic thinking works. I highly recommend reading that one. Apparently, Barnes was asked if he named the book after the Kermode book. Barnes said that he had never heard of the other book, and I have no doubt he is telling the truth. I mean, I don’t think I know anyone who has read Kermode’s book, which is a shame. I wouldn’t say that the books are connected, exactly, but there are definitely some interesting ideas that cross over between them, particularly the way that we make sense of endings (to one the one meaning), and how we sense endings - or think we do. 




Sunday, October 10, 2021

The Lost Gutenberg by Margaret Davis

Source of book: Borrowed from the library.

 

First, let me say that I found this book seriously annoying, despite the compelling story. The reason is that it is written in PRESENT TENSE, exactly as if it were a voiceover for a History Channel documentary. Which is already annoying in the TV medium, but even worse in a book. You know, English has a delightful variety of verb tenses that clarify relationships in time. Plenty of these work well for describing things that take place in the past, and can clarify sequence and relationship. Which is why people writing about the past ought to use them, not take the lazy (and affected) way and write everything with present tense. 

 

The story itself is quite fascinating, however, and it makes it worth suffering through the annoying writing. The title is a bit misleading, in my opinion. The Gutenberg Bible in question is known as #45, and it is the first half of the two-volume set. The other half of this particular one is lost. The book itself is considered particularly valuable because of its excellent “illuminations,” its original leather cover, and its printing on vellum. The condition is particularly excellent. However, the book was never “lost” in any significant way, from what I can tell. The story essentially starts in 1836, when books started appearing for sale in post-revolutionary France, kicked loose from the private collections of aristocrats. While its history between its printing and sale on the open market is not clear, it wasn’t “lost” - it was just in someone’s private library for 300 years. 


 

By 1836, people we beginning to appreciate the historical - and investment - value of certain old books, and Gutenbergs are the first books printed with moveable type in existence. (There are some Chinese and Japanese pamphlets that might qualify, depending on one’s definition. The Gutenberg is clearly the first massive work published that way. 

 

This first recorded sale was for the equivalent of about $6,000 today, which is a good bit less than the $5.4 million it sold for most recently in 1987. Presumably it is worth far more than that now.  

 

After a series of private collectors in England, the book was sold to Estele Doheny, the widow of an oil magnate. She had quite a bit of money, to say the least, and considered herself a modest rival to Henry Huntington as a book collector. However, her money was somewhat tainted by her late husband’s role in the Teapot Dome scandal. He wasn’t convicted, but an official who allegedly took the bribe was. 

 

Speaking of Henry Huntington, I have enjoyed visiting his collection, the Huntington Library and Gardens. He too purchased a Gutenberg, and it is on display at the library. It is not as fine of a copy as #45, and is also incomplete, but it is still amazing to see in person. 

 

On her death, Doheny, a devout Catholic, donated her book collection to the local seminary, intending that it be housed in a memorial library kept open to the public for perpetuity. Because of poor drafting of her bequest, unfortunately, the diocese sold everything off 25 years after her death. 

 

The book was purchased by a Japanese printing company with a history itself dating back a few hundred years. Later, it was donated to Keio University, where it now resides in a vault. Prior to that, the book was carefully photographed, and the pages made available to all online. 

 

Along the way are a bunch of colorful characters, some of who appreciated the book for what it was, and others who didn’t. Lawyers, unfortunately, do not come off all that well in the book. Not only did Doheny’s lawyer botch the bequest, the one lawyer who briefly owned the book seems to have never taken posession of it, or even seen it, before flipping it. 

 

The worst, though, is the Los Angeles Diocese. Good lord, did they fail to appreciate the value of their collection, they appear to have frittered away the sizable sale price for operating expenses, and have essentially nothing left to show for it now. A phenomenally short-sighted and money-focused decision. The man who agitated for the sale even went so far as to claim that the Gutenberg was “Lutheran” - laughable since Martin Luther wasn’t even born until over 30 years after the book was printed. He also claimed that the New American Bibles they had just revised were “intrisingcally more valuable.” Gah! 

 

Ironically, notorious atheist Mark Twain better appreciated the book. The book quotes part of his essay written for the Gutenberg Museum in Germany, and I think it is excellent. 

 

Gutenberg’s achievement created a new and wonderful earth, but at the same time also a new hell. During the past 500 years Gutenberg’s invention has supplied both earth and hell with new occurrences, new wonders and new phases.

It found truth astir on earth and gave it wings; but untruth also was abroad, and it was supplied with a double pair of wings.

What the world is to-day, good and bad, it owes to Gutenberg. Everything can be traced to this source, but we are bound to bring him homage, for what he said in dreams to the angered angel has been literally fulfilled, for the bad that his colossal invention has brought about is overshadowed a thousand times by the good with which mankind has been favored.

 

Much the same could be said of the internet, of course. Printing was there first - and the blessing and curse of literacy is exactly as Twain describes it. 

 

One final bit is worth mentioning. One of the lenses we tend to view history from is that of the “lone genius.” I believe that we do this in significant part because it justifies the “winner take all” model of late-stage capitalism. If the single genius is responsible, then he should get all the profit, right? Except that that is not what actually happens - or ever happened. Technology is and always has been the result of many people working to improve it. It is and always has been the contributions of many - that’s literally how technology and technological progress works. We see that today, of course. Elon Musk didn’t invent the Tesla automobile. Thousands of engineers did. He was the money behind the company, not the actual inventor. Ditto for Apple, and Microsoft, and any tech company you wish to think of. Something to keep in mind when we talk about wealth and income in our public policy. The vast majority of the people who bring us products are actually fairly compensated for their contributions to our society. Rather, it is the people with the money who reap the obscene profits from the work of others. For what it is worth, Gutenberg went bankrupt - it was those who later perfected the process and figured out how to market the books well enough to cover costs. 

 

As I said, the story itself is fascinating and well researched. I found the real-life characters fascinating. Too bad about the writing style.