Source of book: Borrowed from the library
It is difficult to know how to describe this hauntingly sad
book. On its face, it is fantasy. The setting is post-Arthurian England, with
only an ancient Gawain left of Camelot. There are fantastic creatures, a
dragon, and magic. But it doesn’t really read like fantasy.
On another level, it is a parable - and a pretty chilling
one at that. It is also a love story of sorts. And a story of lost and broken
love. It is a quest. But one for which the goals are not revealed until the
end, and even then, answers are lingering in the mist, rather than crystal
clear.
Axl and Beatrice are two elderly Britons, married for a long
time, but unable to remember their past. And it isn’t just them. The entire
country appears lost in this mist of forgetfulness, with only the occasional
memory peeking through the dark.
They set off on a modest quest: to find their son, who lives
somewhere in a village...in that direction. Soon, they meet up with a
mysterious Saxon warrior, Wistan, and a boy, Edwin, rejected by his village
because of his dragon-bite wound. They too are on a quest, but Wistan isn’t
about to disclose it. Sir Gawain too has a quest - to kill a dragon whose
breath appears to be causing the mental mist.
As events unfold, it appears that, somewhere lost in memory,
Gawain, Axl, and Wistan have met before, but nobody can remember why or how.
I’m hesitant to say much more, because it would spoil the
twists and turns.
I do, however, want to talk about the underlying theme.
Forgetfulness in this book isn’t merely personal. It is collective, and it is
an intended forgetfulness. Britain
is a society which has forgotten its bloody origins. The mist obscures the
memories, but the bones are (literally in this book), lurking just below the
surface of those beautiful green meadows.
But don’t think this is just about Britain. If we
look back far enough, each and every one of us has a genocide in our background
somewhere. It is the sad reality of the human race: we are vicious and violent.
One of the things that has struck me about the stories in the Old Testament is
just how much genocide was considered normal in those days. But then, when you
think about it, when has genocide not
been considered normal. Pretty much just the last couple hundred years, at
least in Enlightenment theory? But our own American history starts with a
genocide, and even right now, too many of my white countrymen seem all too
comfortable with ethnic cleansing. This is us, alas. The human instinct toward
tribalism, hatred, and violence, that we struggle to shake even as the best of
us try to transcend. But even as we do, it is impossible to entirely forget the
foundation of bones on which we rest.
This is the chilling core of the book. As any historian of
this period could tell you, the post-Arthurian period (whether or not Arthur
existed as a person is a different matter) was the beginning of a series of
bloody conquests of the British Isles, in
which the culture of the Britons was largely buried along with their bones.
Each wave of conquerors would yield to another in time, until the island, like
its language, would become a hodgepodge of its history.
Kazuo Ishiguro is best known for The Remains of the Day. I must confess, I have never read that book
- or anything else by Ishiguro. I rather suspect this book is a bit
uncharacteristic. However, the writing is beautiful and evocative. My one
complaint is that the plot seems to meander, and the individual incidents are
not always clearly related to the theme and plot - or perhaps, I missed some of
the connections, which is possible. This is one haunting story, though, and I
suspect it will stay with me.
Thanks for the review! I liked Remains of the Day and this sounds so intriguing. I haven't posted much to your blog lately (busy, new position), but I still love your posts and am so glad you are still blogging! Thanks for all the work you put in here!
ReplyDelete